BlogVault vs MainWP

This comparison pits SaaS reliability against self-hosted control and cost savings. BlogVault offers guaranteed, cloud-hosted backup and security, priced per site. MainWP provides a total control, self-hosted management dashboard for unlimited websites. Your perfect fit depends entirely on your data control priorities and scaling needs.

BlogVault
BlogVault

Strong Features, Stellar Reliability, and Support.

Ciroapp review
4.6
#3 in Wordpress Maintenance Service

We find BlogVault provides robust, specialized backup capabilities essential for high-value WordPress sites and agencies. Its focus on guaranteed restoration success and real-time e-commerce protection differentiates it from standard backup tools. Overall, we confidently recommend BlogVault for anyone seeking maximum security assurance and high-quality, responsive customer service.

Pros

  • Guaranteed 100% restoration success rate for crashed sites.
  • Expert and rapid customer support response, praised consistently by users.
  • Includes staging feature that allows testing backups before restoring.
  • Secure cloud storage and enterprise-level security built-in at no extra cost.

Cons

  • Pricing starts higher ($99/year minimum) than basic backup plugins.
  • Limited number of public reviews available to analyze on Trustpilot.
Pricing
$99/mo
Free trialYes
Money-back14 days
Best for
E-commerce businesses demanding zero data loss (hourly backups), Users needing 100% guaranteed site restoration after a crash, Small to mid-sized businesses prioritizing seamless, hosted security and backup
MainWP
MainWP

Self-Hosted Management with Exceptional Control

Ciroapp review
4.8
#1 in Wordpress Maintenance Service

MainWP provides a uniquely powerful, self-hosted solution for agencies seeking total data control and privacy. The non-SaaS pricing model, including a robust free tier and cost-effective lifetime deal, offers immense value. Overall, we find this platform indispensable for serious WordPress professionals managing large client site networks.

Pros

  • Exceptional value via non-SaaS pricing (Forever Free tier, Lifetime Deal).
  • Self-hosted system ensures total data privacy and data sovereignty.
  • Intuitive design makes installation and site syncing easy.
  • Allows bulk actions for plugins, themes, and database optimization.

Cons

  • Some premium add-ons may require separate third-party service subscriptions.
  • Priority ticket support can occasionally experience external communication issues (spam filters).
Pricing
$29/mo
Free trial
Money-back30 days
Best for
Freelancers and agencies managing 20+ client sites, Users prioritizing total data sovereignty and GDPR compliance, Developers needing CLI/API automation for management tasks
Quick verdict
Choose BlogVault if your business demands guaranteed 100% site restoration and real-time (hourly) protection for high-volume WooCommerce sites.
Choose MainWP if you manage 20+ client sites and need a lifetime-deal, self-hosted dashboard offering total data privacy and cost control.

AboutBlogVault

BlogVault is a powerful, time-tested solution for robusting your website backups. It is specifically designed for crucial WordPress sites, serving over 400,000 websites across 120 countries. They have been refining this service for over ten years, successfully backing up more than four million websites. BlogVault automatically configures the plugin for you, ensuring your backups happen easily and reliably. For agencies or business owners, it promises uninterrupted operations and zero-data loss assurance. 💡

AboutMainWP

MainWP is a powerful, self-hosted WordPress manager. You install the free MainWP Dashboard plugin on your own WordPress site, retaining full control and data sovereignty. It’s the centralized solution loved by agencies, developers, and freelancers. This system brings all your necessary administration tasks, like real-time monitoring and bulk updates, into a single, private control center. Installing MainWP is as easy as installing any plugin; it requires no complex server configurations. 💡

Highlights

Quick winners by category at a glance.
Ease of Use (Setup/Out-of-Box)
BlogVault is a simple SaaS setup, configuring automatically in 60 seconds. MainWP requires initial installation on your own hosting.
Feature Set (Dedicated Backup)
BlogVault includes dedicated cloud storage, guaranteed restore, and real-time e-commerce protection. MainWP relies on external plugins for backups.
Value for Money (Agency Scale)
MainWP's fixed pricing structure covers an unlimited number of websites. BlogVault scales costs linearly per site bundle, becoming expensive quickly.
Data Privacy & Control
MainWP is self-hosted, ensuring customer data never leaves the user's private network. This model guarantees total data sovereignty.
Integrated Site Security
BlogVault provides a complete, integrated security suite with a firewall, scanner, and one-click malware cleaner. MainWP manages third-party tools.
Scalability & Management
MainWP is primarily built for bulk administration of unlimited sites. Its core design handles large professional fleets effortlessly.

Feature Comparison

Compare key features side by side
Hosting/Architecture Model
BlogVault:SaaS (Fully Managed)
MainWP:Self-Hosted (Customer's WordPress Site)
Tie
Pricing Structure
BlogVault:Per-Site Annual Subscription
MainWP:Unlimited Sites (Fixed Monthly/Lifetime Fee)
MainWP
Unlimited Site Management
BlogVault:false (Requires site bundles)
MainWP:true
Tie
Core Feature Focus
BlogVault:Backup Integrity & Recovery Guarantees
MainWP:Centralized Bulk Administration
Tie
Real-Time (Hourly) Backups
BlogVault:true (Max Plan for E-commerce)
MainWP:false (Integrates third-party tools)
Tie
Guaranteed 100% Site Restore
BlogVault:true
MainWP:false
BlogVault
Integrated Malware Scanner & Cleaner
BlogVault:true (Built-in)
MainWP:false (Manages third-party tools)
Tie
Integrated Staging Environment
BlogVault:true (One-click staging)
MainWP:false (Requires external tools)
Tie
Included Cloud Storage
BlogVault:true (Up to 100 GB, encrypted)
MainWP:false (Uses local/integrated cloud services)
Tie
Lifetime Pricing Option
BlogVault:false
MainWP:true
MainWP
API / CLI Access
BlogVault:true (API only, Pro/Max Plans)
MainWP:true (API and built-in CLI commands)
Tie
Support Response SLA Guaranteed
BlogVault:true (6-24 hours, depending on plan)
MainWP:false (Priority Ticket Support only)
Tie
Cost Tracking and Budget Tools
BlogVault:false
MainWP:true (Add-on)
MainWP
Open Source Codebase
BlogVault:false (Proprietary SaaS)
MainWP:true
Tie
WooCommerce Transaction Backup
BlogVault:true (Real-time hourly protection)
MainWP:false
BlogVault
Data Sovereignty/GDPR Compliance
BlogVault:BlogVault's EU Servers
MainWP:Customer's Hosting (Total Control)
Tie
Feature Comparison Summary
2
BlogVault
11
Ties
3
MainWP

Features Overview

We highlight the main differences and pick a winner for each feature.

Hosting & Control

BlogVault is hosted SaaS, ensuring convenience. MainWP is self-hosted, providing total data sovereignty.

MainWP

BlogVault operates as a reliable, fully managed SaaS service. Your encrypted backups are stored securely on BlogVault's dedicated cloud servers. This hosted model guarantees easy setup and high uptime for the service. MainWP requires installation on your own WordPress site to function. This self-hosting structure ensures client data remains entirely on your network. MainWP puts privacy first, offering total data sovereignty. The key trade-off: BlogVault is easier and faster to deploy. MainWP grants maximum control and adherence to strict data privacy regulations. MainWP's self-hosting often appeals heavily to GDPR-conscious agencies and developers.

Pricing for Scale

MainWP supports unlimited sites for one fixed fee. BlogVault pricing increases with every site bundle you add.

MainWP

BlogVault charges an annual price per site, starting at $149 for a single-site Plus bundle. Your costs scale linearly if you manage more websites. MainWP offers a robust free Essentials plan for core functions and three Pro plans. These Pro plans, including the $599 Lifetime deal, manage unlimited websites. BlogVault is predictable for managing a very small number of mission-critical sites. MainWP offers exponentially better value as your client roster grows. This difference is massive: BlogVault makes 50 sites very expensive; MainWP handles 50 sites for the same price as five.

Backup Guarantee

BlogVault guarantees 100% restore success. MainWP manages other backup plugins from its dashboard.

BlogVault

BlogVault is engineered purely for backup and recovery integrity, guaranteeing a 100% success rate. It's battle-tested, having protected over 4 million websites. MainWP integrates with many popular backup tools like UpdraftPlus and WPvivid. It centrally manages these tools but relies on their integrity, not native guarantees. For business-critical sites, BlogVault's dedicated focus on recovery is unrivaled. Restoring is one-click, even if the site is completely crashed. Only BlogVault provides specialized real-time, hourly protection specifically for high-volume WooCommerce transactions.

Integrated Security

BlogVault integrates a firewall and cleaner into its service. MainWP manages third-party security plugins.

BlogVault

BlogVault bundles comprehensive security features directly into its plans. This includes a real-time firewall and automatic malware scanning. If malware is detected, BlogVault offers simple one-click removal tools for fast resolution. The Pro and Max plans gain vulnerability scanners. MainWP integrates management for external security tools like Wordfence and Sucuri. Users must still purchase and manage those third-party plugin licenses separately. BlogVault offers a cohesive, all-in-one security and backup suite. MainWP acts as a central control panel for external security services.

Developer Tools

MainWP is open source and offers deep customization tools. BlogVault provides standard API access for integration.

MainWP

MainWP is explicitly built for developers, offering extensive actions, filters, and a REST API. Users can utilize built-in CLI commands for automation. Being open source, developers can inspect all MainWP code or submit pull requests for customization. This provides maximum flexibility for unique workflows. BlogVault includes API access starting with the Pro plan, enabling basic third-party integration. Its focus is on feature reliability, not deep platform customization. Users who need to automate repetitive tasks or integrate management with custom systems will prefer the robust tools offered by MainWP.

Staging Environment

BlogVault includes 1-click staging built-in. MainWP lacks a proprietary staging feature.

BlogVault

BlogVault's feature allows users to create a full staging site instantly. This enables zero-risk testing of themes and plugin updates. Once testing is complete, you can effortlessly merge those changes back to the live site. BlogVault makes safe development seamless. MainWP focuses solely on administration and bulk management tools. It does not natively provide a staging environment creation or management utility. If safe, quick testing is a regular part of your maintenance routine, BlogVault significantly streamlines this development workflow.

Client Reporting & Insight

MainWP offers advanced client reporting extensions. BlogVault focuses on activity logs for debugging changes.

MainWP

MainWP Pro includes extensions like Client Reports and Cost Tracker for agencies. You can manage project costs and generate detailed client-facing reports. MainWP features a Dashboard Insights module providing analytics and usage summaries across the network. This strengthens client communication efforts. BlogVault offers robust Activity Logs to track and debug all changes efficiently. Its primary reporting is centered around backup status and security audits. Agencies needing to bill clients or provide transparent update logs will find MainWP's dedicated reporting tools superior.

Customer Support

BlogVault provides guaranteed support SLAs. MainWP provides Priority Ticket support without a specific guarantee.

BlogVault

BlogVault guarantees response times based on the plan purchased, such as 6-hour or 12-hour windows. This is crucial for business-critical operations. All BlogVault users receive 24/7 expert support across all plan tiers. This clarity offers important assurance during site failures. MainWP Pro users receive Priority Ticket Support, praised by users as fast and effective. A formal, explicit service guarantee (SLA) is not provided by MainWP. If having a guaranteed, verifiable response time is essential, BlogVault provides superior transparency and assurance.

Our Verdict

Objective guidance based on features, pricing, and user fit.

This comparison is about approach: managed reliability versus self-hosted control. Both BlogVault and MainWP are market leaders, but they serve different core needs. If you manage many clients, MainWP is the clear financial winner and provides superior network control. BlogVault's true superpower is providing a total, guaranteed safety net. BlogVault promises 100% successful site restoration, offering unparalleled peace of mind. E-commerce shops must use BlogVault's Max plan for critical hourly, real-time protection. BlogVault also includes integrated site security and seamless, one-click staging environments. MainWP's strength lies in managing unlimited sites efficiently and affordably. MainWP’s self-hosted model ensures maximum data privacy and total sovereignty. Agencies flock to MainWP due to the simple fixed pricing, especially the Lifetime Pro deal. MainWP is built for developers, supporting advanced automation using CLI commands and REST APIs. Your decisive choice depends on your non-negotiables: budget scale or backup guarantee. If you prioritize guaranteed restore SLAs and integrated security, BlogVault is superior. But if you manage 20+ sites and need ultimate privacy with huge cost savings, MainWP is the undisputed champion. Opt for BlogVault if your revenue relies on zero data loss and guaranteed recovery. Choose MainWP if you need agency-level, bulk management controls and wish to maintain total control over your client data infrastructure.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better for dedicated website backups: BlogVault or MainWP?

BlogVault is purpose-built backup software offering a 100% restore guarantee. MainWP does not perform backups itself. Instead, MainWP centrally manages existing backup plugins like UpdraftPlus.

Does MainWP have specialized real-time backups like BlogVault’s e-commerce protection?

No, MainWP lacks the specialized real-time backup capability of BlogVault. BlogVault’s Max plan provides hourly, transaction-level backups for WooCommerce. MainWP focuses on managing existing, periodic backups through third-party integrations.

Which tool is better for agencies managing an unlimited number of clients?

MainWP is far superior for managing unlimited clients due to its fixed pricing model. BlogVault charges per site bundle, making cost scalability difficult for large agencies. MainWP Pro plans handle unlimited sites for one monthly or lifetime fee.

How do BlogVault and MainWP compare on data privacy and control?

MainWP provides maximum data privacy because it is installed on your server. This self-hosted model ensures total data sovereignty. BlogVault is a SaaS tool, meaning client backup data is stored securely on BlogVault’s encrypted cloud servers.

Can I use BlogVault's integrated staging environment with MainWP?

No, BlogVault's dedicated 1-click staging is integrated only within its platform. MainWP lacks a native staging feature. MainWP users must rely on their hosting provider or a standalone staging plugin.

Is BlogVault’s Max plan worth the cost over a MainWP Pro plan?

BlogVault's Max plan is worthwhile for highly critical sites needing its features. It offers hourly backups, integrated security, and a 6-hour support SLA. MainWP Pro is cheaper but requires combining many external tools to match BlogVault’s feature set.

Ready to Choose?

Both tools have their strengths. Choose based on your specific needs.