BigCommerce vs Square Online
BigCommerce and Square Online serve fundamentally different types of businesses. BigCommerce is the high-performance platform for massive scaling and volume. Square Online is the seamless solution for merging retail operations with e-commerce perfectly. Your revenue volume and need for hardware sync should make this decision easy.
Robust tools meet customer service disconnect.
We observe BigCommerce heavily emphasizing high-level enterprise tools, like guaranteed 0% transaction fees and robust infrastructure for scalability. However, user reviews detail severe service issues, including unexpected server outages and deeply unresponsive customer support, even for priority users. Overall, BigCommerce provides impressive technical capability that is unfortunately undermined by inconsistent stability and poor customer experience.
Pros
- Guaranteed 0% transaction fees on the Enterprise plan.
- High reliability with 99.99% reported uptime.
- Industry-leading optimized one-page checkout available.
- Customizable, non-cookie cutter themes compared to competitors.
Cons
- Customer service is frequently reported as unhelpful, non-existent, or indifferent.
- Specific users mention significant, unexpected server downtime (e.g., 25-hour outages).
- Platform infrastructure (CMS, blog system) reportedly struggles with SEO and formatting.
- Essential features like product filters are locked behind high-tier plans.
Seamless integration for retail and e-commerce.
We found Square Online excels at connecting physical retail operations with a user-friendly e-commerce platform, minimizing inventory sync issues. The pricing model, which features a robust free tier and subsequent plans offering lower processing fees, presents clear value for scaling businesses. Overall, Square Online is an excellent, reliable choice, particularly for businesses already leveraging the Square ecosystem.
Pros
- Exceptional ease of setup, navigation, and intuitive user interface.
- Seamless integration between the online store and Square POS (Point of Sale).
- System is highly reliable, stable, and allows sellers to take payments anywhere.
- Strong free plan available ($0/month) perfect for new businesses.
Cons
- Customer service responsiveness and quality are reported as mixed.
- Initial setup can sometimes be challenging for new users requiring detailed guidance.
- Paid plans are charged per location, increasing costs for multi-site operations.
- A 2.5% load fee applies to gift cards on the Free and Plus tiers.
AboutBigCommerce
BigCommerce Essentials is a top-rated ecommerce platform designed specifically for fast-growing businesses, including high-volume operations and B2B SMBs. It operates as a high-performance platform that truly scales with you. Built-in flexibility means you have the freedom to customize your store and save money at the same time. You get robust features that ensure efficient operation, allowing you to focus on expanding your brand and attracting more shoppers. ✅
AboutSquare Online
Square Online is a robust yet easy-to-use platform for building an e-commerce website. You don’t need any coding or web design experience to create a professional site. It caters perfectly to businesses that need their physical store and online sales to sync without hassle. You can start designing a professional site immediately with a free Square account. Square handles the free web hosting, providing exceptional speed, performance, and security for your store. 💡
Highlights
Feature Comparison
Features Overview
We highlight the main differences and pick a winner for each feature.
Scalability Architecture
BigCommerce is engineered for massive volume, B2B, and complex requirements. Square Online provides powerful scaling for retail, but its structure is simpler.
BigCommerce is built for extreme growth, offering headless commerce and unlimited API capabilities. It easily handles multi-currency and complex inventory needs for Enterprise clients. Square Online scales naturally for retail, but its per-location pricing can increase complexity and cost quickly. BigCommerce's Multi-Storefront feature manages multiple sites from a single centralized backend.
POS Integration
Square Online offers seamless, real-time inventory sync with Square POS hardware. BigCommerce relies on external third-party integrations for POS sync.
Square Online automatically connects with Square POS inventory and customer data seamlessly. Orders and stock flow instantly across retail and your online site, preventing overselling. BigCommerce always needs third-party connectors for physical retail, adding integration complexity. The deep, unified commerce approach makes Square Online the clear favorite for brick-and-mortar stores.
Transaction Fees
BigCommerce eliminates platform fees entirely on its highest tier for extreme cost savings. Square Online incorporates fees tied directly to its payment processing model.
BigCommerce Enterprise guarantees 0% additional platform transaction fees, maximizing profit margins for huge sellers. You retain the freedom to choose from over 55 preferred payment providers. Square Online's processing fees range from 3.3% + 30¢ down to 2.9% + 30¢ on paid tiers. While lower costs are offered on Square Online Premium, fees never vanish like they do for BigCommerce Enterprise users.
Ease of Use
Square Online is intuitive and fast, ideal for non-technical users launching quickly. BigCommerce has a steeper learning curve, designed for technical flexibility.
Square Online users consistently praise its quick setup and simple, code-free site builder functionality. You can launch a good-looking site with essential functionality almost immediately. BigCommerce is more robust, offering deeper customization using its Page Builder and customizable themes. However, this power demands a stronger technical understanding from administrators. Use Square Online if simplicity is your top priority.
Infrastructure Reliability
BigCommerce guarantees 99.99% uptime, focusing on mission-critical, high-traffic sales events. Square Online is highly reported as stable, but official metrics are less definitive.
BigCommerce guarantees best-in-class 99.99% reliability, achieving 100% Cyber Week uptime for ten years straight. This provides immense confidence during peak sales periods. However, user reviews detail severe, long outages (up to 25 hours) outside of official testing periods. Square Online is consistently reviewed as systemically stable and highly reliable for general small business operations.
Customer Service Quality
Square Online users report positive, helpful support experiences with fast resolutions. BigCommerce customer service is frequently rated as non-existent and poor.
Square Online offers consistent 24/7 phone support to Premium subscribers and generally receives good reviews for responsiveness. BigCommerce user reviews frequently describe support as unreliable, unhelpful, and difficult to reach. This poor service quality is often cited as a critical failure point even for BigCommerce Enterprise clients. Choose Square Online if reliable customer support is mandatory for your operation.
Our Verdict
The decision between BigCommerce and Square Online hinges on your business complexity and size. For physical retailers scaling online, Square Online is easily the superior choice. If you’re a massive enterprise focused purely on B2B or ultra-high volume, BigCommerce might win. Square Online offers truly seamless, real-time synchronization with your physical Square POS setup. This integration is unmatched, ensuring inventory and orders sync instantly across all channels. The powerful $0/month Free plan lets you start selling immediately with zero monthly subscription costs. Square Online users consistently praise its intuitive setup and helpful customer support and service. BigCommerce’s power lies in its deep architecture and extreme reliability guarantees. It boasts 99.99% uptime, maintaining 100% uptime during Cyber Week for ten straight years. BigCommerce Enterprise allows 0% additional platform transaction fees, which is critical for margin protection. It also provides robust B2B features like Multi-Storefront and full headless capability. The deciding factor is often operational ease versus technical complexity and support. Square Online provides superior ease of use and integrated support for small business needs. BigCommerce offers technical superiority but is consistently undermined by poor customer service quality, according to user feedback. Choose BigCommerce if you are a high-traffic, established B2B business needing deep control. For the majority of small retailers and Square POS users, Square Online is the easier, better-supported solution.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for small businesses: BigCommerce or Square Online?
Square Online is significantly better for small businesses, especially those with a physical presence. It offers a powerful free plan and seamless integration with Square POS hardware. BigCommerce is architected for large-scale, high-volume operations and B2B requirements.
Does Square Online offer lower transaction fees than BigCommerce?
Not necessarily. Square Online processing fees decrease with higher tiers, but BigCommerce Enterprise guarantees 0% additional platform transaction fees. For extreme high volume, BigCommerce will likely result in lower overall fees. Start with Square Online to keep costs low initially.
Can I manage multiple storefronts with BigCommerce and Square Online?
Yes, both can manage multiple storefronts differently. BigCommerce uses the Multi-Storefront feature from one backend dashboard. Square Online manages multiple locations but charges its monthly subscription fee per dedicated location.
Which platform integrates better with physical retail POS?
Square Online integrates perfectly with Square POS, offering unmatched real-time inventory and customer sync. BigCommerce requires external apps and integrations for point-of-sale functionality. Square Online is built for unified commerce.
Is BigCommerce hard to use for beginners starting their first online shop?
BigCommerce is complex, offering more deep customization, resulting in a steeper learning curve for beginners. Square Online is consistently praised for being highly intuitive, code-free, and easy to set up for first-time sellers.
Between BigCommerce and Square Online, which has better user reviews?
Square Online has dramatically better user reviews with a 4.6 rating, often highlighting positive support and ease of use. BigCommerce reviews are poor at 2.2, citing severe server issues and non-existent customer service.
Ready to Choose?
Both tools have their strengths. Choose based on your specific needs.