Sellfy vs Subbly

Sellfy charges 0% platform transaction fees on all sales across every paid plan. This zero-fee structure significantly increases your profitability immediately. You will only pay the standard processing rates charged by Stripe or PayPal. Subbly does not advertise zero platform fees across its pricing tiers. This means that percentage transaction fees are likely charged by the platform itself. Sellfy offers better financial savings, especially for high-volume sellers needing to maintain profit margins. Subbly's true value lies in specialized subscription complexity. For a business processing $5,000 monthly, Sellfy offers considerable savings over any platform charging a 2% fee.

Sellfy allows simple digital subscriptions for creators to stabilize their monthly income. This feature is integrated but not the platform's deepest focus. Subbly is architected entirely around recurring revenue models and robust subscriber lifecycle management. It includes advanced features like custom cancellation reasons. If subscriptions are secondary to your content sales, Sellfy works fine for simple needs. Subbly provides superior control over the subscriber experience. Growing subscription box businesses need Subbly's advanced metric tracking and sophisticated billing logic.

Sellfy includes Product Migration assistance on Business and Premium plans to upload files. Premium users also get Store Design Migration service. Subbly offers a free, guided migration service for businesses moving from complicated systems. Reviewers confirm the transition is smooth and reduces downtime. Subbly removes major headaches for established businesses moving thousands of customer records. Sellfy's focus is on setting up a new creator store quickly. If you have an existing 500+ subscriber list, Subbly's dedicated migration support makes it the safer choice.

Sellfy is built for digital creators, supporting unlimited products and massive file sizes. The Premium plan allows individual files up to 20GB. Subbly is focused on managing the subscriber relationship and billing complexity. It does not advertise extensive large file hosting capabilities. Sellfy is the ideal choice for delivering high-resolution media like 4K video courses or large music library downloads. Subbly excels elsewhere. Creators selling huge course bundles need Sellfy immediately to avoid using external file hosting services.

Sellfy features comprehensive, built-in marketing tools like upselling, cart abandonment recovery, and affiliate programs. It includes up to 50,000 email credits. Subbly supports internal funnels and growth add-ons, but crucial email marketing requires linking to third-party tools. It integrates via Zapier for broader needs. Sellfy offers an immediate, all-in-one solution without needing to integrate and pay for separate email services. This simplifies your tool stack. If maintaining simplicity is key, Sellfy’s unified paid plan ensures all your core growth tools are instantly ready.

Sellfy uses tiered pricing based on expected annual sales volume, capped at $200k on the top plan. Exceeding the cap triggers a 2% overage fee. Subbly appears to use a simpler feature-based model with plans ranging between $7-$24 monthly. This offers predictable operational costs. Sellfy's revenue-based model can feel restrictive and punishes rapid growth mid-year. Subbly allows for more steady budget forecasting. If your sales fluctuate or grow unpredictably, Subbly might offer less financial stress than worrying about Sellfy's revenue cap.

Sellfy is highly reliant on Stripe and PayPal Business for instant payouts globally. This limitation can exclude users in specific regions. Subbly supports Stripe, Braintree, Authorize.net, and PayPal for processing transactions. This range provides better flexibility for merchants. Subbly offers vital options for businesses that might require Authorize.net integration for existing enterprise accounts. Sellfy does not support this. If you operate in multiple regions or need non-standard payment methods, Subbly is the only viable choice here.

Sellfy is a true all-in-one platform for digital, physical product inventory, and integrated print-on-demand services. Creators can launch custom merch easily. Subbly is designed specifically for managing subscriptions, typically recurring service access or curated box shipments. It lacks built-in P-O-D. Sellfy provides a wider variety of ways to monetize creative work beyond service access alone. Choose Sellfy for diverse product lines. An artist wanting to sell both commissioned digital art and t-shirts must choose Sellfy for its P-O-D integration.