Mullvad vs PIA VPN
Mullvad and PIA VPN both offer robust privacy, but their core philosophies radically diverge. Mullvad champions true anonymity with a fixed €5/month price and account number login. PIA VPN focuses on massive scale, unlimited devices, and ultra-fast NextGen servers.
Unmatched Privacy with Fixed Ethical Pricing
We admire Mullvad's radical transparency and ethical pricing structure, setting a benchmark for strictly privacy-focused VPNs. Overall, this service delivers exceptional speed and true anonymity, making it the top choice for discerning users who prioritize security over non-essential streaming access.
Pros
- True anonymity from day one (account number only, no personal data required).
- Remarkably simple, flat-rate pricing (€5/month) since 2009.
- Excellent speeds, high performance, and low latency using WireGuard.
- Supports flexible, privacy-focused payments (cash, crypto with 10% discount).
Cons
- Customer support response times are frequently reported as slow.
- Lack of dedicated, user-friendly apps for key mobile operating systems (iOS/Android).
- Inconsistent unblocking of major streaming services and often blocked by search engines.
Audited Privacy, Unbeatable Long-Term Value
We find Private Internet Access to be a robust, feature-rich VPN option backed by an independently verified No Logs policy and fully open-source applications. Overall, its strong commitment to user privacy, combined with its ultra-low introductory rates and unlimited simultaneous device support, makes it one of the better value propositions in the VPN market today.
Pros
- Strict No Logs policy is independently audited and court-proven.
- Supports an unlimited number of simultaneous device connections.
- All applications are 100% open source, promoting transparency.
- Access to NextGen servers located in 91 countries.
Cons
- No permanent free version or extended complimentary trial available.
- The introductory rate increases significantly upon renewal for the 1 Year plan.
- The standard monthly rate ($11.95) is relatively high.
AboutMullvad
Mullvad VPN is a privacy service built to fight for a free and open internet. They strongly believe society improves when people have the right to privacy. The service works to prevent mass surveillance and censorship. By using a trustworthy VPN, you ensure your online behavior is not treated as a commodity. Mullvad VPN is perfect for anyone seeking a dependable and straightforward method to stabilize their digital freedom. 💡
AboutPIA VPN
PIA is a Virtual Private Network, which serves as a crucial cybersecurity tool. It provides a secure and encrypted internet connection, preventing others from intercepting your data. The service works by rerouting your traffic through private, remote servers, effectively masking your unique IP address in real-time. PIA is built for anyone seeking to regain digital privacy and enjoy secure browsing, whether at home or using public Wi-Fi. It’s simple to use and allows you to protect an unlimited number of devices simultaneously with one subscription. 💡
Highlights
Feature Comparison
Features Overview
We highlight the main differences and pick a winner for each feature.
Anonymity & Signup
Mullvad offers unparalleled anonymity requiring zero personal data at signup.
Mullvad allows users to generate a unique account number instantly. You never need to provide an email or any personal information to Mullvad. This privacy-first approach sets Mullvad apart immediately. PIA VPN uses a standard signup process which implies needing personal information. They focus on post-signup security with rigid no-logs audits. Mullvad’s system minimizes the potential for identity correlation from the very start. Mullvad wins for users obsessed with true, pre-service anonymity and identity separation.
Device Coverage
PIA VPN offers superior value by supporting unlimited devices per subscription.
Mullvad supports concurrent usage on up to five devices per paid account. This limit works well for an individual or a small household. PIA VPN permits truly unlimited devices under a single subscription. This makes PIA VPN extremely cost-effective for large families or users with many gadgets. If you need coverage for more than five devices, PIA VPN is the definite and easy choice. PIA VPN excels in scalability and overall device value for users covering many endpoints.
Pricing Structure
Mullvad's simple, fixed €5 price ensures maximum cost predictability forever.
Mullvad charges a flat rate of €5 per month, a price unchanged since 2009. This transparent fixed cost applies whether you buy one month or one decade. PIA VPN offers varying prices, starting very low ($1/month) but requiring long-term commitments. PIA VPN’s price can rise significantly after introductory deals expire. Mullvad is highly stable and ethical, while PIA VPN requires careful timing to lock in deep discounts.
Server Network & Speed
PIA VPN offers superior global reach and high-capacity NextGen servers.
Mullvad is noted for excellent speed and low latency, especially using the WireGuard protocol. However, Mullvad's IPs are often blocked by external streaming sites and Google services. PIA VPN boasts ultra-fast NextGen servers with 10Gbps capacity in 91 countries. This huge global network (including all 50 US states) reduces congestion and location limits. PIA VPN is better suited for users who need geographical flexibility and reliable streaming access.
Ad & Tracker Blocking
PIA VPN includes the MACE blocker; Mullvad relies solely on third-party solutions.
Mullvad focuses on the core VPN service and does not include an integrated ad blocker feature. Users must install and manage separate tools for tracker mitigation. PIA VPN offers MACE, a dedicated feature blocking ads, trackers, and malware automatically. MACE improves privacy and optimizes browsing speed immediately upon connection. PIA VPN simplifies security by integrating this crucial protection directly into the application.
Advanced VPN Features
PIA VPN has many advanced features that Mullvad deliberately chooses to avoid.
Mullvad focuses on core privacy and explicitly declines complex features like port forwarding. The service prioritizes simplicity and robust security above all else. PIA VPN provides sophisticated options like Multi-hop (double VPN) and Split Tunneling control. PIA VPN also offers a Dedicated IP add-on for stable access to specific services. Users needing fine-tuned control or specialized connections will prefer PIA VPN’s feature depth.
Customer Support
PIA VPN provides responsive 24/7 support while Mullvad's response times are reportedly slow.
External reviews report that Mullvad's customer support can be notably slow across various channels. Mullvad focuses resources on technical infrastructure rather than large support teams. PIA VPN provides 24/7 support via email and live chat for quick issue resolution. PIA VPN's dedicated support is a major advantage for new users or urgent issues. PIA VPN offers a more accessible and traditional support experience.
Our Verdict
Choosing between Mullvad and PIA VPN is less about quality and more about philosophy. Both are excellent, audited VPNs, but serve different masters. If radical anonymity is your absolute top priority, Mullvad is the indisputable winner. You sign up using only an account number, eliminating the need for personal data. Mullvad’s fixed €5 monthly price ensures transparent, predictable budgeting for years to come. PIA VPN's superpower is sheer utility and massive scale for the price point. With unlimited device connections, PIA VPN is perfect for large households. Its 10Gbps NextGen servers across 91 countries ensure fast speeds and excellent global reach. The deciding factor often comes down to device count and desired features. If you need MACE, Split Tunneling, or coverage for more than five devices, PIA VPN is the logical choice. We recommend Mullvad for the privacy purist or advanced user prioritizing non-traceable security. Opt for PIA VPN if you need a feature-heavy, high-value tool covering every streaming device and phone you own.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for device coverage: Mullvad or PIA VPN?
PIA VPN is the clear winner here, offering coverage for unlimited devices per subscription. Mullvad limits usage to a maximum of five concurrently used devices. PIA VPN provides better value for large households or heavy users.
Does Mullvad offer better anonymity than PIA VPN?
Yes, Mullvad’s system offers superior anonymity upon signup. Mullvad only requires a unique account number, eliminating the need for email or personal data. PIA VPN requires a standard account setup, focusing on audited no-logs after registration.
Is PIA VPN worth the extra cost over Mullvad?
PIA VPN can be more cost-effective if you need many features and unlimited devices. Mullvad has a fixed €5/month price, which is very stable. PIA VPN’s long-term discounted plans often make it cheaper for high-feature requirements.
Does PIA VPN offer a feature like MACE, and does Mullvad?
PIA VPN includes 'MACE,' which is an integrated ad, tracker, and malware blocker. Mullvad does not offer this feature. If you want built-in ad blocking, you must choose PIA VPN.
Can I pay for Mullvad or PIA VPN using physical cash?
Mullvad accepts physical cash payments sent by mail for the maximum anonymity possible. PIA VPN does not list physical cash as an accepted payment method, sticking to digital options.
Is a free plan available with Mullvad or PIA VPN?
PIA VPN lists a Free Plan option in its pricing structure, though details are needed. Mullvad does not offer any free plan, stating free services often compromise user data or time.
Ready to Choose?
Both tools have their strengths. Choose based on your specific needs.