HireBeat vs Top Echelon

HireBeat and Top Echelon solve different parts of the recruitment puzzle successfully. HireBeat optimizes in-house team efficiency with video interviews and AI screening. Top Echelon builds a robust, unified platform centered on expansive network collaboration. Your decision comes down to internal process automation versus broad professional reach.

HireBeat
HireBeat

Streamlined ATS for collaborative hiring.

Ciroapp review
3.9
#3 in Applicant Tracking System

We find HireBeat presents a robust, feature-rich solution focused on maximizing time savings and improving team collaboration, offering powerful tools like AI resume screening and video interviews. Overall, this is a strong contender for businesses needing flexible ATS functionality but requiring clearer subscription pricing details.

Pros

  • Offers a flexible $99 'Pay As You Go' pricing alternative per job.
  • Includes advanced features like transparent AI resume screening.
  • Designed specifically to simplify and speed up collaborative hiring workflows.
  • Robust Applicant Tracking System (ATS) centralized into one platform.

Cons

  • Subscription pricing tiers are not explicitly displayed on the website.
  • The conditional 48-hour refund policy is notably strict.
  • No general user feedback or sentiment data was available for analysis.
Pricing
$25/mo
Free trialYes
Money-back2 days
Best for
Internal corporate HR teams prioritizing speed and time savings, Organizations with occasional hiring needs (using the $99 Pay As You Go option), Teams needing efficient on-demand video interviewing to replace phone screens
Top Echelon
Top Echelon

Solid value for growing teams

Ciroapp review
4.2
#2 in Applicant Tracking System

We see Top Echelon as a solid, scalable platform that unifies ATS/CRM and the TE Network for collaboration. Overall, it delivers reliable workflows, strong search, and clear value, though some features are marked as coming soon and pricing clarity could improve.

Pros

  • Centralizes candidate and client data for streamlined workflows
  • TE Network enables collaboration across teams
  • TE Recruit automates repetitive tasks for high-volume hiring
  • Scalable with easy user and client growth

Cons

  • Some features marked Coming Soon (Sequences, Email Inbox Syncing)
  • Pricing clarity could improve; no visible money-back guarantee
  • Standard monthly price not explicitly stated
  • No free plan, only a 30-day trial
Pricing
$75/mo
Free trial30 days
Money-back
Best for
Recruitment agencies and staffing firms needing placements, Teams needing a unified ATS and CRM solution in one platform, Recruiters focused on high-volume placements needing repeatable workflows
Quick verdict
Choose HireBeat if you need fast, in-house team coordination, transparent AI screening, and quick remote video interviews for candidates.
Choose Top Echelon if you are a recruiting agency focusing actively on placements and need a built-in professional network (TE Network) and scalable ATS/CRM unification.

AboutHireBeat

HireBeat is a comprehensive, single platform designed for modern recruitment teams. It acts as a cohesive source for all your hiring activities, from initial sourcing to final interviews. This tool is ideal if you need a centralized structure for recruiters and hiring managers. It successfully brings everything you need into one useful solution. 💡

AboutTop Echelon

TE Recruit™ is the recruiting platform used by recruiters and staffing agencies to streamline workflows, manage talent pipelines, boost team productivity, and close placements faster. TE Network™ is the split-placement network that expands reach, enables collaboration, and helps close placements through a trusted community of recruiting professionals. Together, they form a unified platform that supports success at every step. 💼🤝

Highlights

Quick winners by category at a glance.
Ease of Use
HireBeat emphasizes a streamlined, low-complexity ATS platform without bloat. It aims to be the world's easiest collaborative tool for teams.
Feature Set Depth
Top Echelon provides a deeper, unified ATS/CRM plus the unique TE Network and detailed advanced search tools. HireBeat is more focused.
Value for Money
Top Echelon has explicit, low annual pricing starting at $75/year per account. HireBeat's key subscription prices remain hidden details.
Specialized Tools for Sourcing
The ability to leverage the dedicated Top Echelon TE Network for placements is a unique and valuable sourcing feature.
Candidate Screening Technology
HireBeat offers integrated on-demand video interviewing and transparent AI resume screening as core features. Top Echelon lacks this focus.
Pricing Transparency
Top Echelon provides clear annual and monthly rates for all users. HireBeat hides subscription pricing, complicating the purchasing decision.

Feature Comparison

Compare key features side by side
Primary Focus
HireBeat:Collaborative ATS/Video Screening
Top Echelon:Unified ATS/CRM + Network
Tie
Target Audience
HireBeat:Internal HR/Corporate Teams
Top Echelon:Recruiting Agencies/Staffing Firms
Tie
Pay Per Job Option
HireBeat:$99 (Pay As You Go)
Top Echelon:No
HireBeat
Subscription Pricing Transparency
HireBeat:Not explicitly stated online
Top Echelon:Clear Annual/Monthly rates listed
Top Echelon
AI Resume Screening
HireBeat:Transparent AI Scanning
Top Echelon:Smart-TE AI Automations
Tie
On-Demand Video Interviews
HireBeat:Yes (Core Feature)
Top Echelon:No (Relies on Scheduling)
HireBeat
Recruiting Network Access
HireBeat:No (Internal Focus)
Top Echelon:Yes (TE Network for split-placement)
Top Echelon
CRM Functionality
HireBeat:Basic/Embedded in ATS
Top Echelon:Unified with ATS (TE Recruit)
Tie
Centralized ATS Complexity
HireBeat:Low-Complexity, No Bloat
Top Echelon:Robust, Unified System
Top Echelon
Job Posting Syndication
HireBeat:Automatic (Hundreds, incl. ZipRecruiter)
Top Echelon:Yes (Job Board Integrations)
Tie
Branded Career Website
HireBeat:Yes (Subscription required)
Top Echelon:Yes (Included in all tiers)
Tie
Free Trial Duration
HireBeat:Available (Via Pay As You Go)
Top Echelon:30 Days
Tie
Time-Saving Claim
HireBeat:Saves 100+ hours manual follow-up
Top Echelon:Automates repetitive tasks
Tie
Email/Storage Quotas
HireBeat:Not Specified
Top Echelon:Detailed (5K-10K emails, 10-100 GB storage)
Top Echelon
Money-Back Guarantee
HireBeat:Strict 48-hour conditional refund
Top Echelon:Not explicitly stated
HireBeat
GDPR Compliance Tools
HireBeat:Yes (Fully GDPR Compliant)
Top Echelon:Yes (GDPR & CCPA Tools)
Tie
Advanced Custom Forms
HireBeat:Not Specified
Top Echelon:Yes (Professional/TE Network)
Top Echelon
Required Annual Commitment
HireBeat:No ($99 Option is One-Time)
Top Echelon:Yes (Lowest price is annual)
Top Echelon
Feature Comparison Summary
3
HireBeat
9
Ties
6
Top Echelon

Features Overview

We highlight the main differences and pick a winner for each feature.

Primary Audience

HireBeat serves internal HR teams needing efficiency; Top Echelon serves agency staffing professionals.

Tie

HireBeat is an all-in-one platform for collaborative hiring within an organization. It aims to save 100+ hours of manual follow-up time. Teams benefit from streamlined internal hiring workflows. Top Echelon builds a unified ATS/CRM for recruitment agencies and professional consultants. Its core strength is the powerful external TE Network. This network facilitates partner placements and wider reach. HireBeat is perfect for companies managing their own direct candidate pool. Top Echelon is built specifically for recruiters handling client placement needs. The decision depends entirely upon your business structure and focus.

Pricing Structure

Top Echelon has clear annual pricing; HireBeat offers a transparent Pay Per Job plan but hides subscription costs.

Top Echelon

HireBeat offers a highly flexible $99 'Pay As You Go' option per job posting. Subscription pricing tiers are not displayed openly on their public website. The final cost scales based on specific usage needs like video interviews. Top Echelon clearly lists annual plans from $75 to $135 per year. Their pricing is based on account or agency quotas and includes detailed limits. HireBeat makes immediate, single hiring simpler with its $99 project rate. Top Echelon offers better visibility for long-term recruiter budget planning.

Advanced Screening & AI

HireBeat leverages AI for transparent resume screening; Top Echelon uses general Smart-TE AI for automation.

HireBeat

HireBeat uses transparent AI resume screening technology as a core selling point. This allows internal teams to quickly focus only on high-potential candidates. It helps move past generic applicant clutter effectively. Top Echelon includes general 'Smart-TE AI Automations' in its higher-tier plans. These automations assist with various back-office tasks like sequencing or data processing. HireBeat’s AI focus is clearly dedicated to front-end applicant filtering early on. HireBeat provides a more specific screening function for internal recruiting teams.

Collaboration & Networking

HireBeat simplifies internal team feedback; Top Echelon offers vital external network collaboration.

Top Echelon

HireBeat excels as a collaborative hiring tool for internal teams. It lets hiring managers instantly see all resumes and video interviews securely. Collaboration tools actively speed up internal decision cycles. Top Echelon features the critical TE Network for external partnership collaboration. This network facilitates split placements with a large professional community. The core difference is focused internal efficiency versus expansive external placement reach. HireBeat keeps the detailed collaboration centralized entirely within your organization.

Applicant Tracking (ATS)

HireBeat runs a streamlined, low-complexity ATS; Top Echelon provides a powerful ATS unified with a full CRM.

Top Echelon

HireBeat’s ATS is centralized and designed explicitly to avoid unnecessary software 'bloat' or complexity. It gives internal users exactly the essential tools. The system ensures sharing candidates across departments is tremendously easy. Top Echelon integrates its TE Recruit ATS capabilities with strong CRM functions. This unification centralizes candidate and client relationship information seamlessly. While both track applicants, Top Echelon handles the broader client management lifecycle. Staffing firms benefit greatly from Top Echelon's unified approach.

Video Interviewing

HireBeat features dedicated on-demand video capability; Top Echelon does not list this modern screening tool.

HireBeat

HireBeat excels at replacing slow, manual phone screens with high efficiency. It offers integrated, on-demand video interviews as a core feature. Candidates can record responses flexibly, saving valuable recruiter time. This feature is vital for managing time-zone differences and remote assessments. Top Echelon's capabilities focus more on pipeline management and networking. It seems to require external solutions for dedicated video screening. HireBeat clearly wins if modern remote candidate screening is a key requirement.

Scalability & Limits

Top Echelon uses clearly defined account quotas; HireBeat scales based on less definite usage variables.

Top Echelon

HireBeat subscription usage scales with variables like the number of positions and video screens required. The usage-based model works well for fluctuating internal hiring demand. However, predicting final costs is difficult for subscribers. Top Echelon defines clear account limits like 5K-10K emails and 100 GB storage in its plans. Agencies grow predictably by moving toward the defined TE Network tier. Recruiters can reliably predict costs based precisely on these defined usage buckets. Top Echelon offers superior transparency into feature limits per dollar spent.

Time Efficiency

HireBeat claims specific 100+ hour savings; Top Echelon emphasizes general automation of repetitive tasks.

HireBeat

HireBeat explicitly claims to save teams over 100 hours of manual follow-up time. This gain comes from streamlined video interviewing and collaborative feedback. The platform makes sharing candidate materials instant and effortless. Top Echelon automates repetitive tasks like job postings and scheduling generally. Its focus on shared pipelines also greatly reduces fragmented data entry. However, Top Echelon does not provide a specific measurable hour-saving claim. HireBeat gives internal recruiters a clear metric for improved efficiency.

Our Verdict

Objective guidance based on features, pricing, and user fit.

HireBeat and Top Echelon solve two fundamentally different hiring problems surprisingly well. If your main goal is optimizing internal talent acquisition, HireBeat is your essential winner. Its core features drastically save time managing your direct candidate flow efficiently. HireBeat is excellent for companies actively avoiding overly bloated, complex HR software systems. HireBeat's superpower lies in its candidate assessment features and speed. It offers transparent AI resume screening technology to filter applicants quickly. You can easily replace slow phone screens with flexible, on-demand video interviews. HireBeat achieves significant measured time savings, claiming 100+ hours saved on manual follow-ups for teams. Top Echelon focuses intensely on the specific needs of professional recruiting agencies. Its strength is unifying ATS, CRM, and the crucial TE Network into one platform. Top Echelon provides critical scalability and clear pricing structures for growing placement firms. The extensive TE Network greatly expands client and candidate reach for faster placements. The decisive factor truly is your business model structure. If you are an internal corporate HR team, HireBeat provides superior collaborative screening tools. If you run a staffing agency, Top Echelon's network and unified platform are essential assets. Top Echelon offers incredible starting value despite limited monthly pricing clarity. Final verdict: Choose HireBeat for fast, collaborative, in-house hiring and modern AI screening. Pick Top Echelon if you need a network-driven ATS/CRM for agency placements and client management.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better for internal corporate HR, HireBeat or Top Echelon?

HireBeat is custom-tailored for internal corporate needs and team efficiency. It emphasizes streamlined collaboration and time-saving features like AI screening. Top Echelon focuses primarily on the complex needs of external placement agencies.

Which platform offers dedicated on-demand video interviewing capabilities?

HireBeat is the clear winner for dedicated video features here. It uses integrated, on-demand video to streamline initial candidate assessment effectively. Top Echelon's data does not emphasize this specific modern screening method.

Does HireBeat include a professional recruiting network like Top Echelon?

No, HireBeat focuses solely on internal recruitment workflows and team collaboration. Top Echelon’s unique TE Network allows for lucrative external split-placements among agencies. This network feature is a major differentiator for Top Echelon users.

Is Top Echelon's subscription pricing more transparent than HireBeat's?

Yes, Top Echelon clearly lists annual plans starting at $75/year per user. HireBeat keeps its main subscription pricing tiers private, requiring direct contact. HireBeat does offer a transparent $99 per-job rate, however.

Which software is better for managing high-volume candidate screening?

HireBeat is stronger here due to its specialized tools. The platform includes transparent AI resume screening functionality. It also uses on-demand video interviews to replace time-consuming phone screens efficiently.

How does HireBeat's 'Pay As You Go' option compare to Top Echelon's minimum price?

HireBeat's $99 Pay As You Go is perfect for hiring occasional roles without commitment. Top Echelon starts at $75 per year, which requires an annual subscription commitment. HireBeat provides much greater flexibility for low-frequency users.

Ready to Choose?

Both tools have their strengths. Choose based on your specific needs.