Сравнить

Hive vs Trello

Hive and Trello are both project management heavyweights, but they solve problems differently. Hive is a connected hub that pulls your work from Slack, email, and CRM tools into one place. Trello is a simple, visual Kanban board that gets you organized fast.

Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links for Hive and Trello. If you click these links and make a purchase, Ciroapp may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
Hive
Hive

Powerful hub for connected teams.

Обзор Ciroapp
4.2
#4 in Project Management

We found Hive excels at centralizing work across multiple tools into a single, AI-assisted workspace. Its flexible views and automation are strong assets, though the pricing structure and some user experiences around support warrant careful consideration. Overall, it's a robust choice for teams prioritizing integration and workflow efficiency.

Плюсы

  • Centralizes work from tools like Slack, Salesforce, and email into one unified workspace.
  • Offers flexible project views including Kanban, Gantt, Calendar, and Table.
  • Integrates Buzz AI for smart search, summaries, and turning conversations into tasks.
  • Provides a free forever tier and a free trial with no credit card required.

Минусы

  • Some users report confusion or dissatisfaction with billing and subscription management.
  • Advanced features and support are often reserved for higher-tier, more expensive plans.
  • Requires upfront integration setup to realize its full value, which may not suit all teams.
  • Pricing details for some modules or support levels are not fully transparent upfront.
Цены
$0–$2025
Бесплатная пробная версия
Гарантия возврата
Лучше всего подходит
Agencies managing multiple client projects, Marketing teams coordinating campaigns, Non-profits with complex approval workflows
Trello
Trello

Простое управление проектами, сложный вход в систему

Обзор Ciroapp
3.8
#13 in Project Management

Мы считаем, что Trello быстро приносит исключительную пользу благодаря своей простой работе. Его визуальная организация по Канбану очень гибка для командных рабочих процессов. В целом, Trello — мощный инструмент, но проблемы со стабильностью и раздражающие моменты, связанные с администрированием, такие как вход через Atlassian, действительно сдерживают его.

Плюсы

  • Простой, наглядный дизайн досок Kanban предлагает превосходную простоту использования.
  • Постоянно доступен Бесплатный план, подходящий для небольших команд или личного использования.
  • Платформа эффективна для управления командой и быстрого обмена контекстом.
  • Поддерживает широкие возможности настройки и обновления функционала через Power-Ups.

Минусы

  • Пользователи часто сообщают о трудностях и проблемах с процессом входа в систему Atlassian.
  • Доступ к информации о выставлении счетов и счетам может быть на удивление сложным.
  • Интерфейс время от времени страдает от задержек и простоев сервера.
  • Ключевые представления, такие как Календарь или Карта, требуют платной подписки Premium.
Цены
$0/мес
Бесплатная пробная версияДа
Гарантия возврата
Лучше всего подходит
Startups and small businesses needing a simple, free task tracker, Remote teams that value easy context sharing and real-time sync, Managers who need to visualize simple workflows with Kanban boards
Быстрое решение
Выберите Hive если you want to centralize work from multiple apps like Slack and Salesforce into a single, AI-assisted workspace
Выберите Trello если you need a simple, visual system to organize tasks and don't want a steep learning curve

ОHive

Hive is a project management platform built for teams of all kinds. From agencies and marketing teams to non-profits and education groups, it’s designed to organize collaboration and automate workflows. It’s not just a task list; it’s a connected system where your work happens. 💡

ОTrello

Trello разработан, чтобы вы всегда были на высоте, гарантируя, что каждая задача или идея, независимо от размера, найдет свое надлежащее место. Система помогает вам оставаться организованным и продуктивным, используя три ключевых компонента: Inbox (Входящие), Boards (Доски) и Planner (Планировщик).

Inbox быстро фиксирует задачи, как только они приходят вам на ум, независимо от того, находитесь ли вы в офисе или в пути. Вы управляете своими задачами с помощью гибких Boards, где длинные списки становятся управляемыми, отслеживая элементы от «задач, которые нужно решить» до «миссия выполнена!» Используйте Planner, чтобы просто перетаскивать свои главные задачи прямо в календарь, гарантируя, что вы выделите время для самого важного. 💡

Основные моменты

Быстрые победители по категориям с первого взгляда.
Ease of Use
Trello’s simple Kanban design is incredibly intuitive. 81% of customers choose it for its ease of use.
Feature Set
Hive offers more built-in project views and deeper integration features. Trello’s advanced views require Premium.
Value for Money
Trello’s Standard plan offers unlimited boards and automation at $5/user/month, providing excellent core value.
Customer Support
Both have mixed reviews. Hive offers dedicated CSMs for enterprise. Trello’s support scales with paid plans.
Ничья
Integration Options
Hive acts as a central hub with deep, native integrations. Trello uses modular Power-Ups for connections.
Mobile Experience
Trello’s mobile apps are praised for reliable real-time sync across all devices. Hive’s mobile details are sparse.

Сравнение функций

Сравните ключевые функции бок о бок
Core Interface
Hive:Kanban, Gantt, Calendar, Table, List views
Trello:Kanban boards (Premium adds Calendar, Timeline, etc.)
Ничья
AI Features
Hive:Buzz AI for search, summaries, action item creation
Trello:Atlassian Intelligence for email-to-task conversion
Ничья
Automation
Hive:Automated action and project templates
Trello:Built-in, no-code automation rules on every board
Ничья
Integrations
Hive:Deep integrations with Slack, Salesforce, email, Gong
Trello:Power-Ups for custom integrations, connects Slack, Teams, email
Ничья
Free Plan
Hive:Yes ($0 forever tier)
Trello:Yes (unlimited cards, 10 boards/workspace)
Trello
Starting Paid Price
Hive:$0 (Free) to $12/user/month (Teams)
Trello:$5/user/month (Standard, annual)
Trello
Mobile Experience
Hive:Not specified in detail
Trello:Reliable real-time sync across iOS, Android, Desktop
Trello
File Storage Limits
Hive:Not specified in detail
Trello:Free: 10MB/file; Paid: 250MB/file, unlimited storage
Trello
Card/Task Mirroring
Hive:Not specified
Trello:Yes (Standard plan and up)
Trello
Custom Fields
Hive:Not specified
Trello:Yes (Standard plan and up)
Trello
Reporting Views
Hive:Flexible views (Gantt, Table, etc.)
Trello:Premium: Dashboard, Calendar, Timeline, Map views
Ничья
Security Certifications
Hive:Has a 'Security Overview' page
Trello:SOC2 Type 2, ISO 27001, PCI-DSS certified
Ничья
Support Level
Hive:Varies by plan; Enterprise gets CSM
Trello:Free/Standard: Community; Premium: Local Hours; Enterprise: 24/7
Ничья
On-Premise Option
Hive:Not specified
Trello:No (Cloud-only)
Trello
Adoption Guarantee
Hive:Yes (world's only)
Trello:No
Hive
Краткое сравнение функций
1
Hive
7
Ничьи
7
Trello

Обзор функций

Мы выделяем основные различия и выбираем победителя для каждой функции.

User Interface & Views

Hive offers multiple project visualization views out of the box. Trello’s core is a simple Kanban board, with advanced views locked behind Premium.

Hive

Hive provides Kanban, Gantt, Calendar, Table, and List views. You can switch views per project to match your team's style. This flexibility is great for complex workflows. Trello’s strength is its clean, intuitive Kanban board. To get Calendar, Timeline, or Map views, you need the Premium plan at $10/user/month. Hive gives you more visual options at lower price tiers. Trello forces a trade-off between simplicity and advanced features.

AI & Automation

Hive’s AI searches across connected apps to summarize and create tasks. Trello’s AI focuses on converting emails and messages into tasks.

Ничья

Hive’s Buzz AI can search across Slack, email, and Salesforce. It summarizes information and turns conversations into action items. Automation uses templates for recurring tasks. Trello’s Atlassian Intelligence transforms forwarded emails into structured task cards. Automation is built-in on every board, letting you create rules without code. Hive’s AI is broader, connecting more data sources. Trello’s automation is more accessible on the free plan. Hive’s AI is an add-on on mid-tier plans.

Collaboration & Integrations

Hive acts as a central hub, pulling data from your existing tools. Trello uses Power-Ups to add specific integrations.

Hive

Hive integrates directly with Slack, Salesforce, email, and Gong. It aims to be your single source of truth. Your team can collaborate without switching apps. Trello uses Power-Ups for integrations. You can connect Slack, Teams, and email, but it’s more modular. Card Mirroring helps manage tasks across boards. Hive offers a more unified, out-of-the-box connected experience. Trello’s integration approach is more customizable but requires setup.

Ease of Use & Onboarding

Trello is famous for its simplicity and quick start. Hive’s connected power comes with more initial setup.

Trello

Trello’s Kanban boards are intuitive. 81% of customers choose it for ease of use. You can be productive in minutes. The learning curve is very low. Hive connects your tools, which requires initial setup. Its democratically-built features add power but also complexity. It’s easy once configured, but setup isn’t instant. Trello wins for sheer simplicity and speed to value. Hive requires more upfront investment but offers a more powerful end state.

Pricing & Value

Both offer strong free plans. Trello’s paid plans are cheaper per user for core features. Hive’s pricing is more modular.

Trello

Hive’s free plan is robust. Its Teams plan is $12/user/month. Add-ons like Buzz AI cost extra. Annual billing saves 33%. Trello’s Free plan is excellent. Standard is $5/user/month annually. Premium, with advanced views, is $10/user/month. Enterprise is $17.50/user/month. Trello offers more value for core features at lower price points. Hive’s cost can climb with add-ons but offers a more connected ecosystem.

Mobile Experience

Trello is praised for reliable real-time sync across all devices. Hive’s mobile details are less highlighted.

Trello

Trello users consistently praise its mobile apps. Real-time sync works reliably across iOS, Android, and desktop. It’s great for on-the-go task capture. Hive’s mobile experience isn’t detailed in the provided data. Its focus is on the centralized desktop workspace. Integration depth might be the priority over mobile UX. Trello is clearly the leader here based on user reviews. Hive’s mobile story is less compelling from the available information.

Customer Support & Experience

Hive offers dedicated support on higher tiers. Trello’s support improves with paid plans, but some users report admin friction.

Ничья

Hive’s support varies by plan. Enterprise gets a dedicated Customer Success Manager. Lower tiers use a contact form. Some users report billing confusion. Trello’s support scales with plans. Free users rely on community. Premium gets local business hours support. Users report Atlassian login and billing issues. Both have mixed support reviews. Hive’s enterprise support seems more dedicated. Trello’s admin process frustrates some users.

Security & Compliance

Trello lists specific security certifications. Hive points to a security overview page without detail.

Trello

Trello is SOC2 Type 2, ISO 27001, and PCI-DSS certified. These are strong, verifiable standards. Enterprise includes free SSO with Atlassian Guard. Hive has a 'Security Overview' page. Specific certifications aren’t listed in the provided data. You need to request details during a demo. Trello provides more transparent security information upfront. Hive’s security posture is less clear from public materials.

Scalability & Enterprise

Hive offers per-user pricing up to Enterprise with a CSM. Trello has clear Enterprise tiers with unlimited workspaces.

Ничья

Hive’s Teams plan is $12/user/month. Enterprise details aren’t listed but include a dedicated CSM. Pricing scales with add-ons. Trello’s Enterprise is $17.50/user/month annually. It offers unlimited workspaces and organization-wide permissions. Support is 24/7. Both can scale to large teams. Trello’s Enterprise plan is more clearly defined. Hive’s scalability depends on add-on modules.

Hive Цены
$0 – $12/user/month (Teams plan)

Hive pricing: Hive offers a range of options from a $0 free forever tier to a $12/month per user Teams plan. Subscriptions range from free tools for individuals to robust, feature-rich environments for growing organizations and enterprises alike.

Yearly billing is available to help you save on total costs over time. Monthly plans provide maximum flexibility if you prefer less commitment.

Pricing scales with features, allowing you to pay for only the power you need as your projects grow more complex. Add-ons like Buzz AI and time tracking are extra costs on mid-tier plans, which makes the pricing structure modular and customizable.

Бесплатная пробная версия
Гарантия возврата
Pricing types (AI)
Free plan, Per user pricing, Optional add-ons (e.g., Buzz AI), Monthly/Annual billing
Hive pricing screenshot
Просмотр HiveView Hive pricing
Trello Цены
$0/mo

Стоимость Trello составляет от $0 до $17.50 за пользователя/месяц, с четырьмя планами: Free за $0, Standard за $5/пользователь/месяц (ежегодно), Premium за $10/пользователь/месяц (ежегодно) и Enterprise за $17.50/пользователь/месяц (ежегодно).

Trello предлагает гибкие планы для частных лиц и крупных организаций. Давайте подробнее рассмотрим, что предлагает каждый план, на основе вариантов годовой оплаты.

Free

Цена: $0 USD Поддерживаемые веб-сайты: Не указано явно Лучше всего подходит для: Фиксации дел, базовой организации Политика возврата: Не указано явно Другие функции:

  • Неограниченное количество карточек
  • До 10 досок на Workspace
  • Неограниченное количество Power-Ups на доске
  • 250 запусков команд Workspace в месяц
  • Двухфакторная аутентификация
Бесплатная пробная версия
Да
Гарантия возврата
Pricing types (AI)
Free plan, Per user pricing, Monthly/Annual billing, Tiered plans (Standard, Premium, Enterprise)
Free
Месячные: $0 · Годовые: $0
  • Неограниченное количество карточек
  • Неограниченное количество Power-Ups на доске
  • Неограниченное хранилище (10 МБ на файл)
  • Двухфакторная аутентификация
  • Неограниченный журнал активности
До 10 участников в Workspace; До 10 досок в Workspace; 250 запусков команд Workspace в месяц
Standard
Месячные: $6 · Годовые: $5
  • Неограниченное количество досок
  • Зеркалирование карточек (Card mirroring)
  • Расширенные контрольные списки
  • Пользовательские поля (Custom Fields)
  • Быстрый захват данных с помощью ИИ
1 000 запусков команд Workspace в месяц; Неограниченное хранилище (250 МБ на файл)
Premium
Месячные: $12.50 · Годовые: $10
  • Atlassian Intelligence (AI)
  • Представления: Календарь, Временная шкала (Timeline), Таблица, Панель управления (Dashboard) и Карта
  • Функции администрирования и безопасности
  • Шаблоны на уровне Workspace
  • Простой экспорт данных
Неограниченное количество запусков команд Workspace
Enterprise
Месячные: Не указано явно (Рассчитывается как $210.00 в год / 12 = $17.50) · Годовые: $17.50
  • Неограниченное количество Workspace
  • Разрешения на уровне организации
  • Бесплатный SSO и предоставление пользователей с Atlassian Guard
  • Круглосуточная поддержка администраторов Enterprise
  • Управление публичными досками
Не указано явно (Цена указана за пользователя при выставлении счетов за год)
Просмотр TrelloView Trello pricing

Pricing Notes

Context that may affect total cost of ownership.
  • Hive's free plan is a strong starting point. Its paid Teams plan is $12/user/month. Add-ons like Buzz AI can increase costs.
  • Trello's Standard plan is a low $5/user/month annually, offering unlimited boards and automation. This is great value for growing teams.
  • Hive's pricing includes optional modules, making it modular. Trello's pricing is more straightforward per tier.
  • Both offer annual discounts. Hive states a 33% saving. Trello’s annual pricing is clearly listed.

Pricing Head-to-Head

Who offers better value at a glance.
Cheaper starting price
Free trial available
Ничья
Refund policy
Ничья
Pricing models variety
Ничья
Общий победитель по ценам
Это ничья

Отзывы пользователей

Что пользователи говорят об этих инструментах
Победитель отзывов
Hive
Hive
4.20 reviews

Reviewing Hive's external reputation, we found Trustpilot reviews to be mixed but often positive regarding the product's functionality and customer service responsiveness. Users frequently praise the platform's ease of use and comprehensive features for project management, noting its helpful support team. 📊 On the other hand, some reviews highlight concerns with pricing transparency and occasional billing issues, which can affect overall value perception. ⭐ Capterra's detailed review page was inaccessible due to security restrictions, preventing a full cross-platform synthesis. Based on the available Trustpilot snippets, the sentiment leans towards appreciation for Hive's core toolset and collaborative environment, though experiences with account management and subscription handling are less consistent.

Sarah K.
· Trustpilot
5.0 / 5

Hive has been a game-changer for our marketing team. The ability to see all our projects in different views, like Gantt charts, helps us stay on top of deadlines. Customer support has also been very responsive whenever we had questions.

Обзоров пока нет.
Trello
3.80 reviews

Trello получает неоднозначные, но в целом благоприятные внешние отзывы. Его часто хвалят как замечательное приложение для личной и командной организации.

Пользователи постоянно отмечают его простой дизайн и исключительную простоту использования, что делает его идеальным для стартапов и малого бизнеса, использующего щедрый бесплатный план. Основная полезность, включая динамическое управление блоками и сильную синхронизацию в реальном времени, высоко ценится.

J. S.
· Trustpilot
4.0 / 5

Trello — отличный инструмент, чтобы начать, особенно для малого бизнеса. У него есть надежный бесплатный план, который можно использовать для организации, прежде чем решить перейти на платный. Это прекрасный вариант для стартапов с ограниченным бюджетом.

Обзоров пока нет.
AI conclusion
Hive’s reviews praise its core functionality and support. Trello’s reviews highlight simplicity but frustration with Atlassian login. Hive’s overall rating (4.2) is higher than Trello’s (3.8).

Наш вердикт

Объективное руководство на основе функций, цен и общего соответствия.

For most teams, the choice comes down to simplicity versus connected power. Trello is the king of quick, visual task management. Its Kanban boards are easy to love and faster to learn. If you need to organize work fast, Trello is a fantastic starting point. Hive’s superpower is its integration hub. It pulls your Salesforce data, Slack messages, and emails into one place. The Buzz AI can then summarize and act on that connected information. This saves huge time for teams drowning in different apps. Trello’s superpower is its sheer simplicity and accessibility. You can be productive in minutes, and its free plan is incredibly generous. The no-code automation is also powerful and easy to set up on any board. The deciding factor is your workflow. Choose Hive if your pain is switching between 5+ apps daily. Choose Trello if your pain is disorganization and you need a simple, visual system. Pick Hive if you’re an agency, marketing team, or sales team needing a connected workspace. Pick Trello if you’re a startup, small team, or remote group needing simple organization. Both are great; one fits a connected hub, the other a visual organizer.

Часто задаваемые вопросы

Which is better for small teams: Hive or Trello?

Trello is often better for very small teams. Its free plan is generous, and its Kanban simplicity gets you organized instantly. Hive is better if your small team uses many different software tools that need connecting.

Is Trello's free plan better than Hive's?

They’re both strong but different. Trello’s free plan offers unlimited cards and 10 boards. Hive’s free plan centralizes work but has member and project limits (10 each). Trello wins for basic task lists; Hive wins for connected work.

Can Hive connect to Salesforce and Slack like Trello?

Yes, and deeper. Hive has native integrations with Salesforce, Slack, email, and Gong. It aims to pull all data into one workspace. Trello connects to Slack and others, but often through Power-Ups.

Is Trello easier to learn than Hive?

Yes, Trello is generally easier. Its core Kanban interface is very intuitive. Hive requires more setup to connect your tools, but once configured, it’s also user-friendly. Trello has a faster time-to-value.

Which tool has better mobile apps?

Based on reviews, Trello’s mobile experience is better. Users praise its reliable real-time sync across iOS, Android, and desktop. Hive’s mobile apps are functional but not highlighted as a key strength.

Does Hive have an AI assistant like Trello?

Yes, Hive has Buzz AI. It searches across your connected apps (like Slack, email) to summarize info and create tasks. Trello’s AI focuses on converting emails and messages into task cards. Both use AI to reduce manual work.

Готовы выбрать?

Оба инструмента имеют свои сильные стороны. Выбирайте в соответствии с вашими конкретными потребностями.