My Brand New Logo vs Smashinglogo

Both My Brand New Logo and Smashinglogo use AI for fast, professional one-time logo design. My Brand New Logo wins on transparent, affordable pricing and guaranteed uniqueness. Smashinglogo offers higher-tier digital assets like logo animation and long-term rebranding flexibility. This comparison helps you decide if saving money or securing advanced assets matters more.

My Brand New Logo
My Brand New Logo

Fast, unique AI logos with full rights.

Ciroapp review
4.5
#3 in Logo maker

We recognize My Brand New Logo for its highly automated process that produces unique, professional-grade designs instantly. The clear ownership rights and inclusion of print-ready scalable files offer exceptional value for new businesses. Overall, this is an excellent, fast solution for users needing comprehensive branding files without worrying about recurring subscription fees.

Pros

  • Free generation and customization before paying (try before you buy).
  • Guaranteed unique logo designs created by AI algorithms.
  • Full commercial copyright is included with the purchase.
  • Professional Package provides scalable SVG files and a social media kit.

Cons

  • Basic Package (€19) only offers low-resolution files, limiting utility.
  • Refund policy or money-back guarantee is not explicitly stated.
  • Cost for custom design help (€199) is significantly higher.
Pricing
€19–€199 one-time
Free trial
Money-back
Best for
Solo entrepreneurs launching a new brand with cost constraints., Users who need full commercial rights and scalable SVG files affordably., Anyone prioritizing guaranteed unique AI-generated designs.
Smashinglogo
Smashinglogo

High-Quality Logos, High-Stakes Pricing.

Ciroapp review
3.8
#6 in Logo maker

We found Smashinglogo delivers fast, award-winning logo generation with robust file packages, including social kits and animation assets. However, users frequently express shock regarding the required high one-time purchase price after designing for free. Overall, we recommend this service for businesses prioritizing exceptional logo quality over initial cost transparency.

Pros

  • Award-winning ease of use recognized in graphic design software.
  • Generates varied designs quickly without requiring forced sign-up to start.
  • One-time purchase model avoids ongoing subscription costs for businesses.
  • Full ownership rights guaranteed on all purchased logo packages.

Cons

  • Significant user frustration regarding cost, labeling the site misleading or untrusty.
  • High one-time purchase price ($99.99–$299.99) is a major barrier for casual users.
  • Free downloads are watermarked, making them unusable for professional purposes.
  • Some users report receiving only automated or bot responses to support inquiries.
Pricing
$99.99–$299.99
Free trial
Money-backYes
Best for
Ambitious founders requiring premium dynamic branding assets (animation, video)., Business owners prioritizing long-term brand flexibility and future updates via membership., Teams needing comprehensive branding guidelines and a robust social media kit immediately.
Quick verdict
Choose My Brand New Logo if you are price-sensitive, need a guaranteed unique, high-quality SVG file, and prefer transparent €49 pricing for essential assets.
Choose Smashinglogo if you prioritize high-end digital branding assets like logo animations or need long-term flexibility via a "Rebrand Forever" membership.

AboutMy Brand New Logo

My Brand New Logo is an online tool that puts you in control of your visual branding. The design process works in just three simple steps.

First, you tell the tool your company name, slogan, industry, and favorite color. Next, the system generates endless, unique logo variations just for you.

Finally, you can customize your favorite design until it looks exactly right. It's totally free to create your designs; you only pay when you are happy and ready to use your logo.

AboutSmashinglogo

Smashinglogo is a powerful logo maker built for small and medium businesses all over the world. It provides a highly effective, cost-effective solution for entrepreneurs.

The platform has served over 20 million users across 1000+ industries in 190+ countries. It’s consistently recognized with awards for Best Ease of Use in graphic design software.

Smashinglogo helps you create personalized content by giving you a lot of options for independent work. This powerful tool is designed to be the perfect choice for your professional rebranding needs.

Highlights

Quick winners by category at a glance.
Ease of Use
Both tools are recognized for quick, easy, and automated design generation. Smashinglogo is award-winning, but My Brand New Logo uses a simple 3-step flow.
Tie
Feature Set
Smashinglogo offers advanced assets like logo animation, cinematic intros, and the 'Rebrand Forever' membership. My Brand New Logo includes essential files only.
Value for Money
My Brand New Logo provides the essential high-resolution, scalable logo package (SVG) for only €49, far cheaper than Smashinglogo’s Lite plan.
Uniqueness Guarantee
My Brand New Logo explicitly guarantees that the AI creates unique logo designs every single time. Smashinglogo makes no such guarantee.
Pricing Transparency
My Brand New Logo's lower, clearer pricing structure leads to higher user satisfaction and fewer complaints than Smashinglogo’s pricing.
Long-Term Scalability
Smashinglogo’s Premium plan includes the 'Rebrand Forever' membership, giving users permanent flexibility for future logo updates.

Feature Comparison

Compare key features side by side
Pricing Model
My Brand New Logo:One-time purchase
Smashinglogo:One-time purchase
Tie
Free Design Generation
My Brand New Logo:
Smashinglogo:
Tie
Entry Price (High-Res Files)
My Brand New Logo:€49 (Professional)
Smashinglogo:$99.99 (Lite)
Smashinglogo
Scalable Vector Files (SVG)
My Brand New Logo:
Smashinglogo:Print-Ready Files included (Lite)
Tie
Guaranteed Unique Designs
My Brand New Logo:
Smashinglogo:
My Brand New Logo
Full Commercial Copyright
My Brand New Logo:
Smashinglogo:
Tie
Social Media Kit Included
My Brand New Logo:
Smashinglogo:Business/Premium tiers only
Tie
Custom Logo Animation
My Brand New Logo:
Smashinglogo:True (Premium)
Smashinglogo
Dedicated Branding Guidelines
My Brand New Logo:
Smashinglogo:True (Business/Premium)
Smashinglogo
QR Code Generator
My Brand New Logo:
Smashinglogo:True (Premium)
Smashinglogo
Direct Designer Access
My Brand New Logo:True (€199 option)
Smashinglogo:False (Priority Support only)
Tie
Unlimited Edits/Changes Included
My Brand New Logo:
Smashinglogo:
Tie
Satisfaction/Money-Back Guarantee
My Brand New Logo:Not explicitly stated
Smashinglogo:True (Lite plan only)
Smashinglogo
'Rebrand Forever' Membership
My Brand New Logo:
Smashinglogo:True (Premium)
Smashinglogo
Icon Customization Tool
My Brand New Logo:Smart Shapes (Curves/Form Factors)
Smashinglogo:IconFlex™ (Premium only)
Tie
Cinematic Logo Intro Video
My Brand New Logo:
Smashinglogo:True (Premium)
Smashinglogo
Lowest Tier Price
My Brand New Logo:€19 (Low-Res only)
Smashinglogo:$99.99 (First professional tier)
Smashinglogo
Feature Comparison Summary
1
My Brand New Logo
8
Ties
8
Smashinglogo

Features Overview

We highlight the main differences and pick a winner for each feature.

Pricing & Value

My Brand New Logo offers vital files for far less; Smashinglogo's necessary package is steeper.

My Brand New Logo

My Brand New Logo keeps the entry point low for serious users finding tremendous value at €49. This Professional Package includes the essential scalable SVG files and full copyright. This makes My Brand New Logo the budget champion for immediate high-quality needs. Smashinglogo's entry-level Lite package starts at $99.99 for similar professional files. Users report frustration over Smashinglogo's high cost after designing logos for free. For essential business documents and website usage, My Brand New Logo saves you significant money instantly. The cost difference is the primary consideration here. If your budget is tight, My Brand New Logo delivers the required professional assets for nearly half the cost.

Design Uniqueness

My Brand New Logo guarantees unique AI generation; Smashinglogo relies on a large catalog.

My Brand New Logo

My Brand New Logo explicitly guarantees that its dedicated AI algorithms create unique designs every time. Your final logo is inherently distinct using My Brand New Logo. Smashinglogo highlights access to an enormous catalog of professionally designed, varied options. However, Smashinglogo does not guarantee that the generated designs are 100% unique. If standing out with a truly one-of-a-kind visual identity is your top priority, My Brand New Logo offers certainty. This is a critical edge for brand protection.

Advanced Assets

Smashinglogo excels with dynamic video assets; My Brand New Logo focuses strictly on static files.

Smashinglogo

Smashinglogo's Premium plan unlocks powerful marketing tools for dynamic branding efforts. These include a custom Logo Animation and a full Cinematic Logo Intro video asset. You also get a proprietary QR Code Generator™. My Brand New Logo concentrates on providing high-quality, print-ready, and digital static files. It does not offer any motion graphics, video, or advanced dynamic tools. If you plan to use video marketing or streaming, Smashinglogo provides instant, ready-made dynamic assets. My Brand New Logo users would need a third-party tool for these options.

Designer Support

My Brand New Logo lets you hire a designer; Smashinglogo offers rapid priority customer support staff.

My Brand New Logo

The premium 'Hire a Designer' package from My Brand New Logo (€199) provides professional design assistance. A designer helps with personalized custom refinement of your existing concept. This is perfect for complex final tweaks. Smashinglogo offers dedicated Priority Support for high-tier customers. The support team is described as responding quickly, sometimes even on weekends. Those needing specific aesthetic or professional finishing touches should choose My Brand New Logo's direct designer access. Smashinglogo's strength is faster response times, not custom manipulation.

Future Flexibility

Smashinglogo offers permanent rebrand options; My Brand New Logo doesn't detail post-purchase updates.

Smashinglogo

Smashinglogo’s high-tier Premium plan includes the crucial 'Rebrand Forever Smashing Membership.' This ensures you can permanently update and redownload your brand assets if needs change later. My Brand New Logo allows unlimited free customization before purchasing your final design package. Long-term update pathways or permanent rebrand assurances are not specified. For long-term brand investment and anticipated evolution, Smashinglogo’s 'Rebrand Forever' membership is a major advantage.

Icon Editing

My Brand New Logo offers 'Smart Shapes' editing; Smashinglogo reserves advanced IconFlex™ for Premium users.

My Brand New Logo

My Brand New Logo utilizes intuitive Smart Shapes editing capabilities across its Pro package. This lets users fine-tune curves and form factors easily until perfection is achieved. This customization is easy to access. Smashinglogo offers IconFlex™ for advanced customization but only on its expensive Premium plan. The base plans offer standard layout and color manipulation. My Brand New Logo puts more intuitive, visual-level customization tools into the hands of its general users immediately. Smashinglogo asks you to pay a premium for deeper icon control.

Satisfaction Guarantee

Smashinglogo offers a Guarantee on Lite; My Brand New Logo’s refund policy is not explicit.

Smashinglogo

Smashinglogo gives users confidence by including a specific Satisfaction Guarantee with the Lite plan. This policy addresses concerns about the final product before and after the purchase. The official site for My Brand New Logo does not explicitly state a money-back guarantee policy. Users are advised to review the full Terms of Use before purchase. If having a clear, stated financial safety net matters to you, Smashinglogo provides better assurance upfront. You mitigate risk better with Smashinglogo's Lite plan guarantee.

Review Sentiment

My Brand New Logo has higher overall ratings; Smashinglogo is criticized heavily for perceived hidden costs.

My Brand New Logo

My Brand New Logo maintains a strong 4.5 rating, suggesting consistent satisfaction with file quality and cost transparency. Users feel they receive excellent value for the €49 professional package. Smashinglogo has a lower 3.8 average rating due to highly polarized reviews. Many positive reviews praise the assets, but negative ones highlight extreme frustration over the high purchase price. If you value a reliable, stress-free purchasing process without surprising costs, My Brand New Logo is significantly favored. Smashinglogo's quality is high, but the price point causes friction.

Our Verdict

Objective guidance based on features, pricing, and user fit.

If you're building a new brand, choosing between My Brand New Logo and Smashinglogo depends entirely on your budget and desired assets. For most new business owners, My Brand New Logo delivers the strongest overall value. It helps you avoid the frustrating, high price shock reviewers mention when using Smashinglogo. My Brand New Logo’s superpower is making professional design accessible and truly unique. For roughly half the price, you get the essential scalable SVG file and a social media kit. Its proprietary AI guarantees that your logo is one-of-a-kind every single time. My Brand New Logo is the budget champion for instant, high-quality files. Smashinglogo shines brightly when you require top-tier dynamic and future-proof assets. Choosing Smashinglogo unlocks advanced features like custom logo animation and a cinematic intro video. The unique 'Rebrand Forever Smashing Membership' provides unparalleled long-term brand flexibility. Smashinglogo is the premium choice for a polished, dynamic brand vision. Ultimately, the significant cost spread is the main deciding factor here. My Brand New Logo is far cheaper for the essential file types needed for immediate launching. If your budget is fixed, pick My Brand New Logo and get the guaranteed unique SVG file. If you need advanced video assets and future security, Smashinglogo justifies its higher premium cost. Therefore, choose My Brand New Logo if you need a guaranteed unique, high-resolution logo instantly for under €50. Go with Smashinglogo if your brand requires logo animation, comprehensive guidelines, and the long-term Rebrand Forever option. Both My Brand New Logo and Smashinglogo free you from monthly subscription hassles.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which software offers a cheaper entry point for professional, scalable logo files?

My Brand New Logo is cheaper, offering the Professional Package with scalable SVG files for €49. Smashinglogo’s Lite plan, the first professional tier, costs $99.99 for similar assets. My Brand New Logo provides the better initial value.

Does Smashinglogo offer a better money-back policy than My Brand New Logo?

Yes, Smashinglogo explicitly includes a 'Satisfaction Guarantee' with its entry-level Lite plan. My Brand New Logo does not explicitly state a money-back guarantee or specific refund policy. Review My Brand New Logo's Terms of Use carefully before purchasing.

Which tool is better for creating dynamic video assets, My Brand New Logo or Smashinglogo?

Smashinglogo is superior for dynamic assets, offering custom Logo Animation and a Cinematic Logo Intro video. These features are exclusive to Smashinglogo's highest Premium tier. My Brand New Logo focuses only on providing static, high-resolution files.

Is the logo generated by My Brand New Logo guaranteed to be unique?

Yes, My Brand New Logo guarantees its AI algorithms create unique logos every time, ensuring your design is distinct. Smashinglogo does not offer this specific guarantee but relies on its vast catalog of design options.

Can I hire a professional designer for custom tweaks using My Brand New Logo?

Yes, My Brand New Logo offers a premium option called 'Hire a Designer' for €199. This package connects you with a professional designer for custom refinement work. Smashinglogo does not offer a direct designer consultation service.

Which tool provides better long-term rebranding flexibility: My Brand New Logo or Smashinglogo?

Smashinglogo provides better long-term flexibility via its 'Rebrand Forever Smashing Membership.' This is included in the Premium plan, allowing permanent updates to your assets. My Brand New Logo does not detail an equivalent long-term update path.

Ready to Choose?

Both tools have their strengths. Choose based on your specific needs.