Software A vs IDShield

ID Resolve and IDShield both promise identity protection, but they approach peace of mind differently. IDShield bundles comprehensive cybersecurity and financial monitoring into every plan. ID Resolve offers a lower-cost entry focused strictly on expert resolution after theft occurs. Choosing the right tool depends on whether you seek resolution expertise or a full digital security suite.

S
Software A
Ciroapp review

Pros

    Cons

      Pricing
      See pricing
      Free trial
      Money-back
      Best for
      Cost-conscious users needing only incident resolution services after identity theft., Individuals who prioritize having immediate action from U.S. based recovery specialists., Users who prefer the convenience of selecting an annual billing option.
      IDShield
      IDShield

      Comprehensive protection with expert restoration support.

      Ciroapp review
      4.8

      We found IDShield provides exceptional value by combining advanced monitoring tools with robust, personalized restoration services. Overall, we recommend IDShield highly for individuals and families seeking reliable, expert-backed identity protection.

      Pros

      • Full identity restoration handled by licensed private investigators.
      • High level of customer support (professional and knowledgeable staff).
      • Highly rated, user-friendly mobile application and interface.
      • Comprehensive digital security suite, including VPN and password manager.

      Cons

      • Alerts are not always delivered in real-time, according to some users.
      • Family plans limit dependent coverage to minors under 18.
      • No explicit money-back guarantee or free trial is advertised.
      Pricing
      $14.95/mo
      Free trial
      Money-back
      Best for
      Families requiring comprehensive, defined coverage for minors and dependents under 18., Individuals who require 3-bureau credit monitoring and a monthly score tracker., Users prioritizing maximum financial safety with $3 million identity theft coverage.
      Quick verdict
      Choose Software A if you prioritize having U.S. based specialists handling cleanup immediately and want an affordable resolution-only service.
      Choose IDShield if you need $3 million in identity fraud coverage, 3-bureau credit monitoring, and included cybersecurity tools like a VPN and malware protection.

      AboutSoftware A

      AboutIDShield

      IDShield is a comprehensive identity protection service focusing on monitoring, recovery, and digital security. It is built for anyone needing to monitor their sensitive information and online presence around the clock. You can choose between an Individual Plan or a Family Plan that covers you, a partner, and dependents under 18 living with you. Enrolling only takes a few minutes, granting you immediate access to all available features. ✨

      Highlights

      Quick winners by category at a glance.
      Ease of Use
      User reviews praise IDShield for its professional and user-friendly mobile application and interface. ID Resolve does not have explicit user experience reviews documented in the source data.
      Feature Set
      IDShield offers superior features including $3M coverage, 3-bureau monitoring, PrivacyCheck, and a bundled VPN/malware suite. ID Resolve's feature profile is limited mostly to identity resolution.
      Value for Money
      For only a dollar or two more per month, IDShield overwhelmingly provides greater value. The high coverage limit and included cybersecurity tools make IDShield a much better bargain.
      Customer Support
      IDShield guarantees unlimited restoration service led by licensed Private Investigators (PIs). ID Resolve uses U.S. based specialists but lacks the specialized PI designation for complex cases.
      Pricing Flexibility
      ID Resolve provides more payment flexibility by offering users both monthly and discounted annual billing cycles. IDShield only advertises straightforward monthly payment options.
      Comprehensive Coverage
      IDShield clearly specifies protection across identity, credit, and digital devices. ID Resolve specializes heavily in resolution services while coverage details are often less defined.

      Feature Comparison

      Compare key features side by side
      Individual Pricing Range (Monthly)
      Software A:$13.25 – $22.42
      IDShield:$14.95 – $19.95
      Tie
      Annual Billing Option
      Software A:
      IDShield:
      Software A
      3-Bureau Credit Monitoring
      Software A:No (monitoring is active but bureau count unspecified)
      IDShield:Yes (Optional $19.95/mo plan)
      IDShield
      Identity Restoration Professional
      Software A:U.S. based resolution specialists
      IDShield:Licensed Private Investigators (PIs)
      Tie
      Identity Fraud Reimbursement Coverage
      Software A:Not explicitly detailed (Standard likely)
      IDShield:Up to $3 Million
      IDShield
      Resolution-Only Base Plan
      Software A:Yes ($13.25/mo base plan)
      IDShield:No (Monitoring included in all plans)
      Software A
      Included Virtual Private Network (VPN)
      Software A:
      IDShield:
      IDShield
      Malware & Device Protection
      Software A:
      IDShield:Yes (Up to 3 devices)
      IDShield
      Proactive Data Broker Removal (e.g., PrivacyCheck)
      Software A:
      IDShield:
      IDShield
      Family Plan Structure
      Software A:Spouse coverage available (cost unclear)
      IDShield:Defined plan covering spouse and minors under 18
      Tie
      Monthly Credit Score Tracker
      Software A:
      IDShield:Yes (Included with 3-bureau plan)
      IDShield
      Restoration Service Guarantee
      Software A:Immediate action upon theft
      IDShield:Unlimited service duration until restoration
      IDShield
      Feature Comparison Summary
      2
      Software A
      3
      Ties
      7
      IDShield

      Features Overview

      We highlight the main differences and pick a winner for each feature.

      Fraud Reimbursement

      IDShield offers $3 million in coverage, significantly more than ID Resolve’s unspecified amount.

      IDShield

      ID Resolve does not publicly disclose the limit of its identity fraud reimbursement within its plan details. Users should expect standard industry coverage. This lack of transparency is a drawback for users prioritizing financial safety. IDShield provides a massive financial safety net, offering up to $3 million in identity fraud coverage. This protection covers legal costs and underlying financial losses. This high limit makes IDShield incredibly secure against catastrophic financial loss. The sheer difference in coverage limit ($3M vs. undisclosed standard) makes IDShield the superior, safer choice. Financial security is highest with IDShield. This robust IDShield coverage ensures you are not financially ruined by sophisticated, high-cost identity theft incidents.

      Restoration Experts

      IDShield uses dedicated licensed Private Investigators; ID Resolve uses U.S. resolution specialists.

      IDShield

      ID Resolve employs U.S. based resolution specialists ready to take immediate action upon theft detection. These experts manage the complex cleanup process entirely for the user. ID Resolve promises to save you money, time, and hassle during recovery. IDShield assigns a dedicated, licensed Private Investigator (PI) to handle your recovery case. The PI works for an unlimited time until your identity is fully restored to its pre-theft status. This is a full-service, guaranteed restoration. The licensed PI model from IDShield carries greater weight and provides a stronger, unlimited restoration guarantee. ID Resolve offers expert help, but not the PI designation. If your case requires navigating complex legal or financial institutions, a licensed PI from IDShield is a major benefit.

      Cybersecurity Suite

      IDShield includes a VPN and malware protection; ID Resolve focuses just on identity protection.

      IDShield

      ID Resolve’s plans focus strictly on resolution and identity monitoring tools like dark web checks. ID Resolve does not offer any bundled services for securing devices or internet connection. Users must purchase device protection separately. IDShield includes a comprehensive digital safety suite protecting up to three personal devices. This valuable bundle features a world-class VPN, malware protection, and a password manager. All these are included in the base price. IDShield clearly offers more holistic digital security by integrating network and device protection tools. This bundling adds significant comparative value. ID Resolve doesn't compete in this defensive area at all. For users who want to consolidate their VPN and security software billing, IDShield provides an excellent all-in-one solution.

      Credit Monitoring

      IDShield guarantees 3-bureau monitoring oversight; ID Resolve’s bureau count is unspecified.

      IDShield

      ID Resolve 360 includes active monitoring to detect early signs of trouble. However, the plan details do not specify coverage across 1, 2, or 3 major credit bureaus. This makes comprehensive financial oversight uncertain. IDShield gives users the powerful option of choosing 3-bureau coverage for $19.95 monthly. This definitive coverage monitors Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion simultaneously. The plan includes a monthly credit score tracker. IDShield's explicit option for 3-bureau monitoring makes it far superior for deep financial oversight. ID Resolve primarily markets its resolution service, not its credit depth. If spotting hard inquiries or changes across all three bureaus is crucial, IDShield is the necessary choice.

      Entry Price & Focus

      ID Resolve offers a resolution-only plan for $13.25/mo; IDShield starts slightly higher with monitoring included.

      Software A

      The standard ID Resolve plan is resolution-focused and costs $13.25 monthly for individuals. This is the cheapest path to accessing U.S. based cleanup specialists. ID Resolve caters to those confident in their own monitoring abilities. IDShield begins at $14.95 monthly, but this price includes 1-bureau credit monitoring and the full cybersecurity suite. IDShield does not offer a cheaper resolution-only tier. ID Resolve offers a lower barrier to entry if you strictly want the safety net without active credit monitoring. IDShield provides more features for a marginal increase in price. If cost is the single most important factor, ID Resolve saves you $1.70 per month on the base plan.

      Proactive Privacy

      IDShield includes PrivacyCheck to remove data from brokers; ID Resolve lacks this proactive tool.

      IDShield

      ID Resolve uses technology to check places you cannot for suspicious data use. This detection is mainly passive, alerting you to compromised information. ID Resolve does not advertise tools for removing data from public sources. IDShield features the innovative PrivacyCheck tool to proactively locate your data on broker sites. You can then request removal to prevent data selling and re-exposure. This actively manages your digital footprint. PrivacyCheck gives IDShield a decisive advantage in proactive privacy management and data suppression efforts. ID Resolve relies on monitoring rather than direct action. Using PrivacyCheck with IDShield helps reduce spam and limits the information third parties can collect about you.

      Family Coverage

      IDShield has a clear Family Plan structure; ID Resolve only confirms spouse coverage is available.

      IDShield

      ID Resolve states that spouse coverage is available but does not specify the cost publicly. Details regarding dependent children protection or clear family plan enrollment are not provided. IDShield offers a standardized Family Plan starting at $29.95 monthly. This plan explicitly covers the primary member, spouse, and dependent children who are under 18 years old. The explicit inclusion of minors and a defined family price structure makes IDShield far easier to adopt for families. ID Resolve's family options are less transparent. Parents concerned about their children's identity being exposed should choose the defined coverage offered by IDShield.

      Our Verdict

      Objective guidance based on features, pricing, and user fit.

      If you are struggling to decide between ID Resolve and IDShield, we recommend IDShield for superior protection. IDShield is our overall winner thanks to its comprehensive feature bundle and robust safety net. ID Resolve is a solid contender, but IDShield delivers notably stronger financial assurance and digital tools. ID Resolve shines by offering an affordable, resolution-only service starting at $13.25 monthly. This base plan is cheaper than any offered by IDShield. You receive access to U.S. based resolution specialists who take immediate action when theft occurs. Choose ID Resolve if you are a cost-conscious user focused purely on guaranteed expert cleanup efforts. IDShield delivers exceptional value, starting at just $14.95 monthly for individuals. Every IDShield plan carries up to $3 million in identity fraud coverage, a substantial safety net. Furthermore, IDShield uses dedicated licensed Private Investigators for unlimited restoration efforts. IDShield bundles valuable extras like a world-class VPN and comprehensive credit monitoring. The critical difference is whether you need resolution or resolution plus prevention. Choose IDShield if you need comprehensive device security and definitive 3-bureau credit monitoring. IDShield is also the better, more transparent choice if you need a clear Family Plan covering minors. ID Resolve is sufficient if you only need the cleanup piece. Pick ID Resolve if you want the absolute lowest cost resolution service and prefer annual billing options. But for unmatched financial coverage, comprehensive monitoring, and a licensed PI guarantee, IDShield is the clear overall choice. IDShield provides the superior and more valuable total security package.

      Frequently Asked Questions

      Which offers better financial coverage: ID Resolve or IDShield?

      IDShield offers significantly higher protection, providing up to $3 million in identity fraud coverage. ID Resolve does not publicly define its reimbursement limit, suggesting standard coverage. For a superior financial safety net and protection from complex losses, choose IDShield without question.

      Does ID Resolve offer a VPN and device protection like IDShield?

      No, ID Resolve focuses only on core identity resolution and monitoring services. IDShield includes a complete digital safety suite at no extra cost. The IDShield bundle provides a world-class VPN, password manager, and anti-malware protection for up to three devices.

      Which is cheaper: ID Resolve or IDShield?

      ID Resolve has a slightly cheaper entry point at $13.25 per month for its resolution-only plan. IDShield starts at $14.95 per month, which includes monitoring and cybersecurity tools. ID Resolve is cheaper, but IDShield offers considerably better value through integrated features.

      Is 3-bureau credit monitoring available with ID Resolve?

      ID Resolve 360 includes active monitoring, but the number of credit bureaus it monitors is not explicitly stated. IDShield clearly offers a choice between 1-bureau and comprehensive 3-bureau monitoring. IDShield is better for maximizing financial oversight.

      Who handles the identity restoration for ID Resolve vs IDShield?

      ID Resolve utilizes U.S. based resolution specialists who take immediate action post-theft. IDShield assigns a dedicated, licensed Private Investigator (PI) who works for an unlimited time. IDShield's PI model provides a guaranteed, expert-level restoration service.

      Which is better for families: ID Resolve or IDShield for dependents?

      IDShield is better for families due to its standardized Family Plan starting at $29.95 per month. The IDShield plan clearly covers dependents under 18 years old. ID Resolve offers spouse coverage, but the specific dependent policies are unclear.

      Ready to Choose?

      Both tools have their strengths. Choose based on your specific needs.