ARMember vs SureMembers

ARMember and SureMembers are top WordPress membership plugins, but they serve different needs. ARMember is the comprehensive all-in-one powerhouse focused on security and community tools. SureMembers is known for its unmatched ease of use and streamlined access control. One is for ultimate features; the other for ultimate simplicity.

ARMember
ARMember

Robust membership tool with exceptional support.

Ciroapp review
4.6
#2 in Membership plugin for WordPress

ARMember provides enterprise-level functionality for comprehensive WordPress membership management. We found the feature set robust, particularly the multi-site support and advanced content dripping options. Overall, we recommend ARMember for established businesses seeking a powerful, reliable solution with stellar customer support.

Pros

  • Customer support is prompt, responsive, and highly dedicated to resolving issues.
  • Comprehensive, all-in-one feature set with 57+ inbuilt Addons included.
  • Flexible monetization models, including proration and Pay Per Post.
  • Intuitive, clutter-free administrative back end and easy setup wizard.

Cons

  • Image upload functionality for member profiles can be overly restrictive.
  • Security protocols sometimes cause “false positives” on uploaded files.
  • Free plan has limited support and features only two payment gateways.
Pricing
$0/mo
Free trialYes
Money-back14 days
Best for
Large creators needing flexible Pay Per Post monetization strategies, Users building community platforms requiring BuddyPress/BuddyBoss integration and gamification, Businesses needing access to a wide variety of global payment gateways (20+ providers)
SureMembers
SureMembers

User-Friendly Access Control for WordPress

Ciroapp review
4.3
#3 in Membership plugin for WordPress

We observe SureMembers delivering on its promise of being an exceptionally simple and fast way to set up content restriction. Its integration focus is robust, though we note that advanced monetization requires adopting the full SureCart and SureTriggers ecosystem. Overall, this is a top-tier WordPress membership plugin offering high usability and strong flexible features.

Pros

  • Exceptionally user-friendly setup and clean interface.
  • Granular control for restricting content, including sections within a page.
  • Seamless integration with SureCart, SureTriggers, and WooCommerce.
  • Effective content dripping and scheduling features.

Cons

  • Professional functionality requires implementing the SureCart/SureTriggers ecosystem.
  • Some users report that the documentation and tutorials are outdated.
  • Highly polarized feedback exists regarding customer service response times.
Pricing
$59/mo
Free trial
Money-back14 days
Best for
Solopreneurs prioritizing the fastest possible content restriction setup, Users committed to the SureCart and SureTriggers product ecosystem for automation, Agencies or developers managing a large portfolio of client sites (up to 100 sites)
Quick verdict
Choose ARMember if you operate a complex educational platform needing group enrollment, specific content throttling, and built-in social community features
Choose SureMembers if you prioritize speed, usability, and integrating seamlessly with the modern SureCart/SureTriggers ecosystem for payments and automation

AboutARMember

ARMember is a complete, turn-key WordPress Membership Plugin. It streamlines all required features for creating a successful subscription service. This tool supports multidimensional businesses, including those selling online courses, building large communities, offering digital content, or providing corporate training. It gives you symmetrical management features, simplifying the way you monetize your WordPress site. ✅

AboutSureMembers

SureMembers is the versatile WordPress Membership Plugin designed specifically for securing and managing content. This powerful tool provides secure and tailored protection for any type of business. Whether you are an influencer crafting a Patreon-like experience or a course creator managing complex cohorts, SureMembers adapts to your needs.

Built by experienced industry veterans, SureMembers simplifies member management into a clear process. You simply create an Access Group, select the content you want to monetize, and decide how to manage any unauthorized visitors. It turns complex content restriction into a straightforward task. 💡

Highlights

Quick winners by category at a glance.
Ease of Use
SureMembers is consistently praised for its clean interface and rapid, simple setup process. Its access rules are highly centralized and easy to manage quickly.
Feature Set
ARMember offers a comprehensive suite, including dedicated features like gamification, Pay Per Post, and Group Membership add-ons. It's truly all-in-one.
Value for Money
SureMembers offers a $599 Lifetime deal for heavy users (100 sites). ARMember provides better starting value with its permanent Free tier and lower entry pricing.
Tie
Customer Support
ARMember users widely report prompt, highly responsive, and effective support that resolves complex issues. SureMembers reviews on support are currently more polarized.
Monetization Flexibility
ARMember wins due to its built-in capacity for Pay Per Post and wide array of payment gateways (21+). SureMembers relies on standard integrations.
Scalability (Sites)
SureMembers' premium tiers support up to 100 websites. ARMember offers strong management features but caps site usage at 10.

Feature Comparison

Compare key features side by side
Content Restriction Level
ARMember:Full Page, URL, Partial (Shortcode)
SureMembers:Full Page, URL, Section within Page
Tie
Monetization Models
ARMember:Subscriptions, One-Time, Pay Per Post
SureMembers:Subscriptions, One-Time
Tie
Group/Corporate Membership
ARMember:
SureMembers:
ARMember
Dedicated Community Tools
ARMember:
SureMembers:
ARMember
Gamification (Badges, Points)
ARMember:
SureMembers:
ARMember
Drip Content Scheduling
ARMember:Time-based, Post-Expiration
SureMembers:Scheduled Release
Tie
Lifetime Purchase Option
ARMember:
SureMembers:
SureMembers
Permanent Free Plan Available
ARMember:
SureMembers:
ARMember
Built-in Security Features
ARMember:Brute Force Protection, IP/URL Restriction
SureMembers:GDPR compliance focus
Tie
Setup Guided Wizard
ARMember:
SureMembers:
ARMember
Number of Payment Gateways
ARMember:21+
SureMembers:Limited (SureCart/WooCommerce focus)
ARMember
Max Supported Sites (Top Tier)
ARMember:10 Sites
SureMembers:100 Sites
SureMembers
Menu Item Visibility Control
ARMember:
SureMembers:
SureMembers
Bulk User Edit/Management
ARMember:
SureMembers:
SureMembers
Feature Comparison Summary
6
ARMember
4
Ties
4
SureMembers

Features Overview

We highlight the main differences and pick a winner for each feature.

Content Protection

SureMembers protects specific sections within a page; ARMember uses shortcodes for partial content control.

SureMembers

ARMember secures content via full page protection, specific URL rules, and shortcodes. It handles posts, pages, and custom post types easily, focusing on comprehensive coverage. SureMembers excels in granular control, protecting specific sections *within* a page easily. This allows for superior content teasers and highly tailored upgrades without custom coding. While both secure entire posts, SureMembers offers a slightly more flexible boundary for immediate restriction. For creators who need to monetize small snippets of premium content quickly, SureMembers’ section protection is highly valuable.

Monetization Models

ARMember supports the unique Pay Per Post model; SureMembers focuses on standard subscriptions.

ARMember

ARMember provides flexible models including recurring subscriptions, one-time fees, and unique Pay Per Post access. It handles proration and parallel memberships for maximum revenue streams. SureMembers integrates seamlessly with SureCart and WooCommerce for standard subscription payments and plans. Its primary focus is on standard tiered membership models. The key difference is ARMember's built-in Pay Per Post functionality for upselling specific content items. SureMembers achieves monetization primarily via external cart integrations. Choose ARMember if your revenue strategy relies on selling access to individual articles or digital downloads.

Ease of Setup & Use

SureMembers is faster and simpler to deploy; ARMember includes a helpful Setup Wizard tool.

SureMembers

ARMember offers an exclusive Setup Wizard to guide new users through essential configurations and payment procedures. Its backend is described as intuitive and clutter-free. SureMembers users consistently praise the platform's ability to set up complex rules quickly in one central location. Its focus is speed and minimal clutter. SureMembers holds the edge for day-to-day usability and speed, simplifying access rule creation substantially. If speed and minimizing the learning curve are crucial, SureMembers proves the faster choice for restriction deployment.

Payment Gateways

ARMember supports 21+ gateways directly; SureMembers requires external SureCart/WooCommerce integration.

ARMember

ARMember’s Professional plan supports over 21 payment gateways globally, including Razorpay, Mollie, and Skrill. This offers high flexibility for international sales. SureMembers relies on connecting to external payment processors, primarily through SureCart or the extensive WooCommerce ecosystem. This requires separate configuration steps. ARMember provides superior built-in gateway connectivity immediately within the plugin structure. SureMembers requires the full integration with its proprietary external tools. Global businesses selling in obscure markets should strongly consider ARMember for its direct, wider gateway support.

Community Features

ARMember offers built-in social and gamification tools; SureMembers focuses solely on access control.

ARMember

ARMember explicitly promotes integration with BuddyPress and BuddyBoss for advanced forums and social networking features. It includes customizable member profiles and directories. SureMembers focuses purely on protecting content and managing access, not on fostering peer-to-peer social communities. It lacks built-in gamification elements. If building a vibrant, interactive community platform is a core requirement, ARMember is the much better choice. Use ARMember if you need public profiles, forums, and gamification to boost member loyalty and reduce churn.

Lifetime Option

SureMembers offers a valuable Lifetime tier; ARMember is exclusively standard annual subscriptions.

SureMembers

ARMember operates solely on annual subscriptions, ranging from $69 (1 site) to $299 (10 sites). All plans require yearly renewal for continued updates and support investment. SureMembers provides a Business Lifetime deal for $599, offering 100 sites with lifetime updates and support. Installment payments are also an option for this top tier. The availability of a one-time payment for SureMembers’ top tier significantly improves its long-term value proposition. Individuals or agencies focused on minimizing recurring operational expenses should view the SureMembers Lifetime deal as a massive benefit.

Site Limits & Scale

SureMembers supports up to 100 sites; ARMember scales up to only 10 sites maximum.

SureMembers

ARMember’s highest tier, the Enterprise Plan, supports usage on a maximum of 10 WordPress websites annually. This tier costs $299 per year with access to top features. SureMembers' Business and Business Lifetime plans support up to 100 sites. This scaling is ideal for large agencies or developers managing huge portfolios of client sites. SureMembers clearly beats ARMember in terms of scalability for professional developers and agencies managing numerous assets. If your business involves frequent client projects, SureMembers provides ten times the site coverage on its premium plans.

Administrative Tools

SureMembers excels at bulk user management; ARMember focuses on secure enrollment flows.

Tie

ARMember offers streamlined management via its Setup Wizard and includes advanced coupon management features. It prioritizes securing the user signup lifecycle against spam and brute force. SureMembers simplifies administration with Bulk Edit Users and specialized features for smooth data migration from other systems. It makes user data management painless. Both tools offer efficiency, but in different areas based on priority. SureMembers is preferred for efficient user cleanup or massive group assignment changes post-launch or during migration.

Our Verdict

Objective guidance based on features, pricing, and user fit.

This decision comes down to feature depth versus raw simplicity and scaling power. SureMembers is the clear winner for ultimate speed and ease of use out of the box. ARMember provides superior community features and flexible monetization tools right within the plugin. If you need a powerful, feature-rich one-stop shop, ARMember is likely your champion. ARMember's superpower is its all-in-one nature and commitment to exceptional customer support delivery. It offers built-in gamification, Pay Per Post monetization, and advanced Group Membership features. ARMember is perfect for educational sites needing specific content expiration rules and community building. Its wide compatibility with over 21 payment gateways is crucial for global sellers. SureMembers excels with its streamlined interface and amazing scalability for busy developers. It makes content restriction incredibly simple, even allowing protection of specific page sections instantly. SureMembers' generous 100-site license and the valuable Lifetime purchase option reduce long-term costs significantly. If you use SureCart for payments, SureMembers creates a fast, modern ecosystem. The core deciding factor should be your required complexity and scale of operations. If you need robust social tools and unique monetization like PPP, ARMember is built for that comprehensive depth. If you manage 10+ sites and prioritize unrivaled simplicity, SureMembers provides better long-term scaling and powerful administration. Choose ARMember for advanced feature sets and comprehensive support for complex businesses. Go with SureMembers if you manage many sites and prioritize the fastest, cleanest access control possible.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which plugin offers better support for external payment processors?

ARMember has the clear advantage in payment gateway support integration. Its Professional plan supports 21+ gateways globally, including many regional providers. SureMembers focuses primarily on seamless configuration with SureCart and WooCommerce. ARMember offers more built-in flexibility for diverse payment methods.

Is SureMembers worth the extra cost over ARMember for large agencies?

Yes, for large agencies the SureMembers value is superior due to scaling. SureMembers offers access for up to 100 sites for $199/year or $599 lifetime. ARMember only supports 10 sites on its most expensive $299 annual tier. SureMembers provides far better infrastructure licensing for large development portfolios.

Does ARMember or SureMembers have a permanent free version to test?

ARMember is the only one offering a permanent free version for testing. This includes limited features and 19 add-ons for core functionality use. SureMembers requires paying upfront but offers a reliable 14-day money-back guarantee for risk-free evaluation.

Which is better for building interactive social community features?

ARMember is significantly better for community building and member engagement. It includes built-in gamification features like badges and points. ARMember also offers flawless integration with BuddyPress and BuddyBoss for advanced forums and profiles. SureMembers offers only access control.

Can I sell access to content on an article-by-article basis?

Only ARMember explicitly supports the specialized Pay Per Post (PPP) method of monetization. This allows you to charge for access to specific, individual articles or premium posts quickly. SureMembers focuses primarily on selling access via standard subscription tiers.

Which plugin offers protection for specific sections inside a post?

SureMembers takes the lead in content granularity by offering protection for specific sections within any page. ARMember supports partial restriction, but this requires manual shortcode implementation by the user. SureMembers provides a simpler, more surgical control over content display.

Ready to Choose?

Both tools have their strengths. Choose based on your specific needs.