Beautiful.ai vs Keynote

Beautiful.ai and Keynote represent two distinct approaches to presentation software today. Beautiful.ai uses powerful AI and Smart Slides to automate design and speed up creation time. Keynote offers deep design control and seamless cross-platform flexibility via Keynote for iCloud. Picking between them depends heavily on whether you prioritize speed or customization.

Beautiful.ai
Beautiful.ai

抛光演示文稿,快速制作。

Ciroapp 评论
3.8
#5 in Presentation

Beautiful.ai 在自动化设计复杂性方面表现出色,使用户能够以最小的努力创建视觉上令人惊叹且专业的文稿。其核心 AI 功能非常出色,可生成高影响力的视觉效果并显着提高专业人士和团队的生产力。然而,我们必须指出,关于账单惯例的反复抱怨,特别是免费试用取消后产生的不需要的年度收费,确实影响了整体用户体验。总而言之,它是一个用于视觉质量的强大工具,前提是您仔细管理您的订阅。

优点

  • AI 生成功能可以根据文本提示快速创建全面的演示文稿草稿。
  • 智能幻灯片 (Smart Slides) 自动处理复杂的设计、格式和间距。
  • 用户报告演示文稿创建时间大大减少,称之为革命性的变化。
  • 输出的幻灯片具有高质量、专业且视觉效果令人印象深刻。

缺点

  • 试用取消后,意外的年度账单付款会反复出现问题。
  • 支持响应不一致,尤其是在解决账单纠纷时。
  • 模板和幻灯片格式有时会显得统一或对于高级定制来说过于有限。
  • 用户报告难以在幻灯片之间复制粘贴图像或元素。
Pricing
$45/mo
Free trial14 days
Money-back1 days
最适合
Teams needing to produce high-volume, visually polished decks quickly, Sales or Marketing teams requiring Salesforce/Slack integration and slide analytics, Organizations needing strict brand compliance via Locked Slides and centralization
Keynote
Keynote

出色的软件,存在问题的支持生态系统。

Ciroapp 评论
3.4
#6 in Presentation

我们认为 Keynote 是一款强大可靠的演示工具,提供无缝的跨平台集成和先进的协作功能,适用于任何现代团队。总的来说,虽然该软件性能出色并提供强大的功能,但其整体价值因用户对苹果当前客户支持框架的普遍、有据可查的不满而受到负面影响。

优点

  • 通过原生 App 和网页访问(Windows/iCloud)实现跨平台使用。
  • 强大的协作功能,用于共享演示文稿。
  • 强大的设计控制、主题和轻松设置。
  • 专为虚拟演示而设的功能(单独的演讲者备注)。

缺点

  • 定价和具体的订阅套餐没有透明披露。
  • 用户对基本的苹果客户支持的评价非常低(1.7 星)。
  • 有关于生态系统计费和订阅问题的普遍报告。
Pricing
未明确说明
Free trial
Money-back
最适合
Users deeply embedded in the Apple ecosystem (Mac, iPad, iPhone), Designers requiring limitless creative control and bespoke customization tools, Virtual presenters who need a dedicated, private screen for notes on a Mac
快速判断
选择 Beautiful.ai 如果 need to generate high-volume, highly polished presentations fast and require Salesforce/Slack integration and team analytics
选择 Keynote 如果 are deeply embedded in the Apple ecosystem (Mac, iPhone, iPad) and require powerful, manual design control over every element

关于Beautiful.ai

Beautiful.ai 是一款专为专业人士和团队设计的智能创意伙伴。它可以让您花费一半的时间来制作出色的演示文稿。该平台使用独特的智能幻灯片 (Smart Slides),它们会自动处理设计、布局和间距。💡

当您添加或编辑内容时,幻灯片会即时调整。这意味着您可以跳过格式设置工作,完全专注于故事和信息。它非常适合简化工作流程并确保团队保持一致。

关于Keynote

Keynote 是苹果设计的一款多功能演示工具。它能帮助您快速设置专业的演示文稿。您可以先选择一个主题,然后立即添加新幻灯片。它专为 Mac、iPhone 和 iPad 用户设计,为您提供灵活性。通过 Keynote for iCloud,Keynote 还将覆盖范围扩展到了 Windows 用户或偏爱网页界面的用户。它提供了制作和分享视觉故事的基本工具。💡

亮点

按类别快速查看获胜者。
Ease of Use
Beautiful.ai's Smart Slides automatically handle all design principles, freeing the user to focus only on content. Keynote requires more manual formatting.
Feature Set
Beautiful.ai offers AI generation, centralized team assets, locked slides, and business tool integrations. Keynote's features are more focused on design and device continuity.
Value for Money
Beautiful.ai provides clear tiers and costs, allowing easy budgeting. Keynote's unknown pricing prevents a concrete value assessment against Beautiful.ai.
Cross-Device Flexibility
Keynote provides seamless, native access across Mac, iPhone, and iPad, which Beautiful.ai cannot match.
Core Design Control
Keynote gives users powerful, manual design controls for full creative customization. Beautiful.ai restricts control for the sake of automation.
Integration Options
Beautiful.ai integrates directly with professional business tools: Salesforce, Slack, and Dropbox.

功能比较

并排比较关键功能
AI Presentation Draft Generation
Beautiful.ai:Full draft from prompt
Keynote:
Beautiful.ai
Automatic Slide Formatting (Smart Slides)
Beautiful.ai:Yes (300+ layouts)
Keynote:No (Manual design control)
Beautiful.ai
Real-time Collaborative Editing
Beautiful.ai:Yes (Team plan)
Keynote:Yes (Across platforms/iCloud)
平局
Native Apple Device Consistency
Beautiful.ai:No
Keynote:Yes (Mac, iPad, iPhone)
Keynote
Web Browser Access (Windows/iCloud)
Beautiful.ai:
Keynote:
平局
Centralized Slide/Asset Library
Beautiful.ai:Yes (Team plan)
Keynote:Not specified
Beautiful.ai
Locked Slides (Brand Guardrails)
Beautiful.ai:Yes (Content protection)
Keynote:
Beautiful.ai
Export to PowerPoint (PPTX)
Beautiful.ai:
Keynote:
平局
Offline Presentation Delivery
Beautiful.ai:Yes (Desktop player)
Keynote:Yes (Native apps)
平局
Viewer/Slide Analytics
Beautiful.ai:Yes (Team plan)
Keynote:
Beautiful.ai
Business Integrations (Salesforce, Slack)
Beautiful.ai:
Keynote:
Beautiful.ai
Dedicated Presenter Notes (Virtual)
Beautiful.ai:Not specified
Keynote:Yes (Separate window on Mac)
Keynote
Teams: SCIM/SSO Support
Beautiful.ai:Yes (Enterprise)
Keynote:Not specified
Beautiful.ai
Minimum Users for Team Plan
Beautiful.ai:2 Seats
Keynote:Not specified
Beautiful.ai
Pricing Transparency
Beautiful.ai:High (Clear tiers)
Keynote:Low (Not explicitly stated)
Beautiful.ai
Feature Comparison Summary
9
Beautiful.ai
4
Ties
2
Keynote

Features Overview

我们强调主要差异并为每个功能选择获胜者。

AI Automation & Speed

Beautiful.ai uses AI to automate design and accelerate deck creation significantly.

Beautiful.ai

Beautiful.ai immediately generates full presentation drafts from a single text prompt. Smart Slides automatically handle design, layout, and spacing adjustments instantly. Users report being up to 80% more efficient creating decks with Beautiful.ai. Keynote starts with professional themes but requires the user to execute the design choices manually. It offers powerful control but lacks the instant AI generation or automatic formatting found in Beautiful.ai. The major trade-off is control versus instantaneous results; Beautiful.ai handles the repetitive design work. Keynote demands more hands-on design but provides greater creative freedom and customization. If you need to produce 5 new, polished decks per week, Beautiful.ai dramatically reduces time sinks. If design ownership and granular control matter more, Keynote is better.

Cross-Platform Access

Keynote works natively on all Apple products and widely via iCloud; Beautiful.ai is cloud-first.

Keynote

Beautiful.ai operates primarily as a web app, offering flexible access via standard web browsers. It also provides a desktop player for offline presentation delivery when internet is unavailable. Keynote is deeply integrated across Mac, iPad, and iPhone, ensuring true cross-device consistency. Keynote for iCloud allows full access and editing via any compatible web browser, even Windows machines. Keynote offers a true native application experience across Apple devices that Beautiful.ai cannot match. However, both tools allow Windows users to collaborate through a web browser effectively. Keynote is ideal for an all-Apple office that needs browser flexibility for external partners and seamless device handover.

Team Collaboration

Both offer real-time editing, but Beautiful.ai adds centralized assets and crucial analytics.

Beautiful.ai

Beautiful.ai's Team plan includes real-time live editing and a centralized slide and template library. It features version control, plus lockable slides for managing strict brand consistency. Keynote facilitates strong collaborative functionality, allowing seamless editing and sharing across various platforms, including the web browser interface. Beautiful.ai provides advanced features like viewer and slide analytics, which are absent in Keynote's listed features. Keynote's collaboration is built around core document sharing principles. For large teams requiring strong asset control and tracking engagement, Beautiful.ai provides superior management and organizational tools.

Workflow Integrations

Beautiful.ai focuses on business integrations; Keynote focuses heavily on Apple device integration.

Beautiful.ai

Beautiful.ai integrates directly with professional tools like Salesforce, Slack, Dropbox, and Monday.com. This enables streamlined workflows and critical presentation reporting insights. Keynote's strength lies in its deep integration within Apple's ecosystem (Mac, iPad, iPhone). Specific external, non-Apple business software integrations are not listed in its features. Beautiful.ai clearly wins for integrating presentations directly into your sales and marketing tech stack. Keynote offers superior integration with your owned Mac, iPhone, and iPad devices. If tracking slide views, efficacy, and sharing metrics matter, Beautiful.ai's Salesforce integration is critical for sales groups.

Design Control

Beautiful.ai guarantees polish via rules; Keynote gives the user ultimate, manual creative freedom.

Keynote

Beautiful.ai uses Smart Slides to enforce professional design and brand compliance automatically. While efficient, this rule-based system can feel uniform or too limited for advanced, unique customization. Keynote offers powerful design tools, themes, and controls, allowing users hands-on command over every element. Users can tailor the visual story exactly. Beautiful.ai sacrifices fine-grained control for speed and guaranteed polished output. Keynote sacrifices design speed for virtually limitless creative freedom. If you are a professional designer or require truly bespoke layouts, Keynote gives you the full canvas you need.

Virtual Presenting

Keynote excels in virtual calls with a dedicated presenter view for Mac users.

Keynote

Keynote, when used on a Mac, includes a dedicated feature to keep presenter notes and slide controls in a separate private window. The audience only views the presentation slides. Beautiful.ai touts flexible sharing and delivery but focuses on content creation and export functions. Specialized features for virtual meeting delivery are not mentioned in its details. Keynote's dedicated feature significantly improves delivery quality during mission-critical virtual conferences. It focuses the presenter on their notes and timing discreetly. If you frequently deliver complex virtual presentations with detailed notes, Keynote offers a unique and distinct organizational advantage.

Pricing Visibility

Beautiful.ai has transparent, tiered pricing; Keynote's costs are not disclosed in the documentation.

Beautiful.ai

Beautiful.ai provides clear pricing tiers for individuals and teams, ranging from $12/month up to custom enterprise quotes. It includes specific feature lists for each level. Keynote's documentation does not explicitly detail costs, subscription packages, or billing cycles for the software. Users must consult external Apple stores for current pricing information. Beautiful.ai allows potential customers to estimate collaboration costs quickly and accurately for budgeting purposes. Keynote requires extra research to determine the final price. Keynote's lack of transparent pricing makes Beautiful.ai a clearer budget choice for teams needing predictable financial accounting.

我们的判断

基于功能、价格和用户适配的客观指导。

Beautiful.ai and Keynote are presentation heavyweights built with completely different design philosophies. Beautiful.ai is the clear choice for speed and efficient, automated visual polish. Keynote is best if you demand the highest level of creative control living inside the trusted Apple device ecosystem. Beautiful.ai’s true superpower is making everyone look like a brilliant designer instantly. Its Smart Slides feature automates all formatting, helping you generate comprehensive presentations within seconds using powerful AI. Teams get massive efficiency gains, plus crucial administrative tools like analytics and locked slides for strict brand control. Keynote’s strength lies in its powerful creative canvas and legendary device reliability. Designers love the deep manual control over design elements and professional themes. It works perfectly on your Mac, iPhone, and iPad, letting you edit or present seamlessly on the go. Keynote for iCloud also ensures external Windows users can easily collaborate. The deciding factor is speed versus control. If you need a polished business deck almost instantly, and need to track audience engagement, choose Beautiful.ai. But if your slides require truly bespoke design treatments, and native Mac integration is non-negotiable, Keynote is your superior tool. Choose Beautiful.ai if your team needs to output 50 polished decks a month while strictly enforcing brand consistency. If you value personal creative freedom and use a dedicated Mac for complex virtual presentations, Keynote remains the industry standard choice.

常见问题

Which is easier to use for beginners: Beautiful.ai or Keynote?

Beautiful.ai is generally easier for design beginners due to its Smart Slides feature. Smart Slides automatically handle complex layout and formatting adjustments instantly. Keynote offers powerful tools but requires more manual effort to achieve a polished look.

Does Keynote offer AI content generation like Beautiful.ai?

No, Keynote does not offer AI presentation draft generation from a text prompt. Beautiful.ai can generate a full deck in seconds using its custom GPT and AI writing assistant. Keynote focuses on starting with professional themes and user-directed content.

Which tool is better for enterprise-level brand control?

Beautiful.ai is better for large organizations requiring strict brand control and compliance. Its Team and Enterprise plans include Locked Slides and centralized libraries. Keynote offers design controls but lacks these centralized brand guardrails.

Can Windows users collaborate on Keynote presentations?

Yes, they can. Keynote for iCloud allows Windows users to create, edit, and collaborate on shared presentations easily. Windows users access the document directly through a compatible web browser interface.

How much does Beautiful.ai cost versus Keynote?

Beautiful.ai has transparent pricing, starting at $12/month when billed annually. Keynote's pricing is not disclosed in the documentation; users must rely on Apple's external app stores. Therefore, Beautiful.ai is easier to budget for immediately.

Which software is better for tracking audience engagement?

Beautiful.ai is explicitly better for tracking engagement. Its Team plan includes viewer and slide analytics to track audience interaction. There is no mention of built-in analytics or viewing reports within Keynote's feature set.

准备好选择了?

这两个工具都有各自的优点。根据您的具体需求进行选择。