Audacity vs Auphonic

Audacity and Auphonic solve completely different problems in the audio world. Audacity is a powerful manual editor, free forever, if you enjoy hands-on control. Auphonic is your dedicated AI engineer, automating difficult post-production work for consistency. Which tool you choose depends completely on your desired workflow.

Audacity
Audacity

強力で無料の音声エディター。安定性が課題。

Ciroappレビュー
3.9
#2 in Audio Editing

Audacityを無料のオープンソース音声編集における主要な選択肢として認識しています。強力な価値、クロスプラットフォームサポート、詳細な分析ツールを提供します。全体として、繰り返し発生する安定性の問題と新しいバージョンにおける複雑さが、信頼できるプロフェッショナルなDAWとしてのその可能性を妨げていると見ています。

長所

  • 完全な音声編集機能を提供する、完全に無料のオープンソースソフトウェア。
  • Windows、macOS、Linuxオペレーティングシステムに対応したクロスプラットフォームサポート。
  • シンプルで機能的なインターフェースは、基本的な効果音や作業に最適です。
  • VST3プラグインをサポートし、高度な詳細音声分析機能を提供します。

短所

  • 頻繁なクラッシュ、持続的なバグ、プロジェクト復旧の問題を含む信頼性の問題。
  • リアルタイムのアナログ入力を正確にキャプチャするのに苦労する新しいバージョン(3.2.xなど)。
  • ユーザーはインターフェースを古く「全く直感的でない」と表現しています。
  • 一部のプロのユーザーは、音の出力品質がこもっているか平坦であると批判しています。
Pricing
$0/mo
Free trial
Money-back
最適
Hobbyists with a zero budget., Sound designers needing deep, manual waveform manipulation., Users who require robust VST3 plugin support for complex effects.
Auphonic
Auphonic

プロのための自動サウンドエンジニアリング。

Ciroappレビュー
4.3
#1 in Audio Editing

Auphonicは、高度なレベリングやノイズリダクションなどの機能を備え、さまざまなメディアタイプで一貫した放送品質を実現するための堅牢でAI駆動のソリューションを提供すると考えられます。全体として、信頼性の高い自動化された後処理ワークフローを必要とするクリエイターやプロフェッショナルにとって、Auphonicをお勧めします。

長所

  • 信頼性の高いプロフェッショナルなオーディオ品質で100万以上のユーザーに信頼されています。
  • ノイズおよび残響リダクション機能が非常に効果的(完全かつ正確に除去)。
  • 直感的なデザインと簡単なユーザーインターフェース。
  • 柔軟な処理時間オプション(永久無料プラン、定期購入、都度購入クレジット)。

短所

  • 外部ユーザーのフィードバックによると、処理速度が遅くなる場合がある。
  • 料金階層はクレジットに基づいており、公式の通貨コストは事前に公開されていません。
  • 定期的な月次クレジットは繰り越しできません。
Pricing
$20/mo
Free trial
Money-backYes
最適
Weekly podcasters needing perfect, consistent loudness leveling quickly., Producers requiring automated shownotes and chapter markers., Audiobook masters needing strict adherence to commercial loudness specifications.
クイック判定
選択 Audacity の場合 You need a full-featured, $0 solution for deep audio cutting and creative sound design on Windows, macOS, or Linux.
選択 Auphonic の場合 You produce consistent podcasts or audiobooks weekly and need perfect, automated loudness leveling and noise reduction instantly.

についてAudacity

Audacityは、音声を操作したり、音声でクリエイティブな作業をしたりする必要がある人にとって最適なアプリです。世界で最も人気のある音声編集・録音プログラムとして、多くの異なるニーズに対応します。ポッドキャストの制作、音楽の作成、新しいサウンドファイルで試すなど、Audacityは理想的です。どのような理由であれ、ファイルをすばやく編集またはエクスポートする必要がある場合に、この多用途なツールが役立ちます。何よりも、Audacityは誰にとっても完全に無料であり、誇りを持ってオープンソースです。オーディオ愛好家からなる熱心な世界中のコミュニティが、日々ソフトウェアの共同開発と改善を続けています。💡

についてAuphonic

Auphonicは、あなたの専用AIサウンドエンジニア ✨ として機能するように設計されています。これは、さまざまな種類のメディアファイルに対する後処理作業を処理します。このスマートなサービスは、オーディオブック、ラジオ放送、教育ビデオの処理を特にサポートしています。もしあなたがポッドキャスターなら、このツールはあなたの制作ワークフロー全体を簡単に簡素化できます。強力なインテリジェンスと使いやすさを組み合わせて、毎回プロフェッショナルなサウンドを提供します。

ハイライト

カテゴリ別のクイック勝者を一目で確認。
Ease of Use
Auphonic simplifies complex mastering into a clean, automated workflow. Audacity has an archaic interface that is often non-intuitive.
Feature Set
Audacity has deep manual editing and VST support, which Auphonic lacks. Auphonic dominates automated leveling and AI workflow efficiently.
引き分け
Value for Money
Audacity costs $0 and offers powerful audio editing capabilities for free. Auphonic is excellent but requires payment for serious usage requirements.
Noise Reduction Quality
Auphonic uses superior AI algorithms that completely and correctly eliminate noise and reverb. Audacity's noise tools are manual and less refined.
Scalability/Automation
Auphonic offers advanced workflows like Watch Folders ideal for high-volume content. Audacity is strictly a manual, project-by-project editor.
Stability
Auphonic ensures stable, server-side processing for guaranteed results. Audacity is currently plagued by reported crashing and severe bugs.

機能比較

主要な機能を並べて比較
Primary Function
Audacity:Manual Audio Editor
Auphonic:Automated Post-Production Service
引き分け
Cost
Audacity:Free (Forever)
Auphonic:Credit-based (Usage/Subscription)
引き分け
Interface Type
Audacity:Desktop Application
Auphonic:Cloud/Web Service
引き分け
AI Leveling (Volume Consistency)
Audacity:Manual (Compressor plugins)
Auphonic:Intelligent Leveler (Automated)
引き分け
Automated Noise Reduction
Audacity:Manual (Effect application)
Auphonic:Highly Automated & Correct
引き分け
Reverb Reduction
Audacity:
Auphonic:
Auphonic
Output Loudness Standardization
Audacity:Manual Check/Adjust
Auphonic:True (Adheres to specs)
引き分け
Multitrack Editing
Audacity:
Auphonic:Limited (Multitrack processing)
Audacity
VST3 Plugin Support
Audacity:
Auphonic:
Audacity
Open Source
Audacity:
Auphonic:
Audacity
Platform Compatibility
Audacity:Windows, macOS, Linux
Auphonic:Web Browser (OS agnostic)
引き分け
Free Access Tier
Audacity:Full Software Free
Auphonic:2 hours/month (Jingle included)
引き分け
Workflow Automation (Watch Folders)
Audacity:
Auphonic:True (Paid plans)
Auphonic
Speech Recognition/Shownotes
Audacity:
Auphonic:True (Paid plans)
Auphonic
External Storage Integration
Audacity:
Auphonic:True (Dropbox, Google Drive, SFTP)
Auphonic
Deep Audio Analysis (Spectogram)
Audacity:
Auphonic:
Audacity
Project Instability/Crashing
Audacity:Known Issue
Auphonic:Not applicable (Cloud processing)
Audacity
Feature Comparison Summary
5
Audacity
8
Ties
4
Auphonic

Features Overview

主な違いを強調し、各機能の勝者を選びます。

Core Purpose

Audacity is a flexible, open-source editor for hands-on creativity. Auphonic is a highly specialized cloud service that fully automates mastering.

引き分け

Audacity is an open-source desktop application focused on deep, manual audio editing. You have full control over the waveform, cutting, and applying specific effects instantly. It's built for those who want to get their hands dirty. Auphonic functions as an AI sound engineer, relying on algorithms for consistency. You upload a file, and Auphonic returns a fully processed, broadcast-ready product. It is designed to remove the need for manual mixing entirely. Audacity demands your time and editing expertise to master tracks correctly. Auphonic saves you time and guarantees professional consistency using automated processing. The two tools accomplish quality audio in vastly different ways. Since Audacity focuses on detailed editing and Auphonic focuses on automated finishing, they often complement each other.

Pricing Model

Audacity is completely free, relying on open-source contributions. Auphonic uses a usage-based, complex credit system for processing time.

Audacity

The core Audacity application is completely free forever with no hidden costs or subscriptions. This zero-cost model makes Audacity accessible to students and hobbyists globally. Third-party plugins or the Audio.com companion may incur separate costs. Auphonic operates on a processing credit system, charging based on output duration. It offers a permanent free plan giving 2 hours of processing monthly. Paid credits (recurring/one-time) are required for high volume or advanced features. Audacity’s transparency is unbeatable for budget conscious users; its price is zero. Auphonic's credit system can feel opaque, as currency costs are not always transparently published upfront. Auphonic works for professionals; Audacity works for everyone. Auphonic's free 2 hours allows robust testing of its AI quality before you commit to purchasing any processing credits.

Loudness & Leveling

Auphonic automatically adheres to strict broadcast loudness standards. Audacity requires manual adjustment of compression and leveling effects.

Auphonic

Users must manually apply complex compressors and limiters within Audacity to achieve consistent volume. While Audacity features powerful tools, consistency relies entirely on the user's mixing skill. This manual process is often time-consuming and prone to error. Auphonic features the Intelligent Leveler, ensuring volumes are perfectly consistent and adhere to specifications instantly. Auphonic meets all required loudness standards for platforms like radio and podcasts automatically. This automation guarantees smooth, professional results every time. If professional consistency is critical, Auphonic is the clear superior choice for process reliability and speed. Audacity requires expert knowledge and significant manual effort for the same result. Auphonic completely eliminates the mastering learning curve. Podcasters especially benefit from Auphonic since it auto-corrects levels between multiple remote speakers effortlessly.

Noise Reduction

Auphonic features highly effective, automated noise and reverb reduction. Audacity provides useful but entirely manual noise gating and reduction tools.

Auphonic

Audacity offers reliable noise reduction tools, which require sampling the initial noise floor first. This feature is effective for basic ambient humming or static removal. The quality depends heavily on careful user tweaking of process parameters. Auphonic's algorithms are praised for completely and correctly eliminating background noise and troublesome reverb. This critical clean-up step is seamless and automated after file upload. Users report being highly impressed with Auphonic's overall accuracy. For clean, professional audio, Auphonic’s AI delivers superior, less destructive noise removal automatically. Audacity's tools are functional but often require aggressive settings that can degrade overall sound quality. Auphonic is the clear efficiency choice. Use Auphonic to save hours cleaning up noisy source audio, letting you focus editing time in Audacity on other creative elements.

User Interface & Experience

Audacity’s interface is often described as archaic and confusing for new users. Auphonic provides a simple, modern, web-based workflow.

Auphonic

Many users describe the Audacity interface as challenging and outdated, limiting modern ease of use. Tutorials often fail to match the application's current behavior in newer versions. Its workflow is complicated for beginners learning digital audio. Auphonic benefits from an intuitive design and easy-to-understand web interface based on clear steps. The platform simplifies the complex technical process of mastering audio. Users praise the simple process: upload, select preset, process, and download finished audio. Auphonic wins heavily on user experience by automating complexity through a clean interface. Audacity's extensive feature set is often buried under an old, unstable user experience. Usability is a common complaint against Audacity's recent releases. If you prefer a clean, browser-based, step-by-step approach, Auphonic will feel instantly familiar and accessible.

Advanced Workflow

Auphonic excels at automation with Watch Folders and automatic notes. Audacity requires tedious manual effort for every single step.

Auphonic

Every step in Audacity—from applying noise reduction to mixing tracks—is manual and requires user intervention. Audacity provides no inherent tools for batch processing or automated file monitoring. It is strictly a project-by-project editing tool. Auphonic's paid plans unlock sophisticated automation features, including Watch Folders that automatically process new uploads. Auphonic can also generate automatic shownotes and chapter markers using speech recognition. This saves massive time for high-volume content creators. For serious podcasters or professionals with high volume, Auphonic is designed to scale and streamline process flow. Audacity simply cannot compete with Auphonic's advanced automation capabilities. This level of AI saves hours every week. If you routinely process 10+ hours of audio per month, Auphonic’s automation becomes a necessary advantage over Audacity.

Stability & Reliability

Audacity suffers from known instability and crashes in newer versions. Auphonic offers reliable, consistent processing in the cloud model.

Auphonic

Recent reviews highlight Audacity's significant stability issues, including crashing and project recovery failures. This instability means relying on Audacity for critical, large projects can be inherently risky. Bugs have been reported in previously reliable features. Auphonic's processing happens reliably server-side; if a production fails, you are not charged credits. This cloud model offers reliability and consistency, ensuring successful output. The result quality is professional and predictable every time. Audacity’s instability is a major drawback for professional daily use, despite its free nature. Auphonic offers peace of mind with reliable, predictable results. Stability is a key difference between the two tools. For tight deadlines and critical workflows, the dependable cloud architecture of Auphonic is clearly safer than an unstable application like Audacity.

Integration Ecosystem

Audacity supports local VST/Nyquist plugins for creative effects. Auphonic integrates with cloud storage services for streamlined file transfers.

引き分け

Audacity is a powerful host for third-party plugins, supporting VST3 and Nyquist formats. This robust support allows deep customization of effects and sound design. Users can leverage Muse Hub for access to additional processing tools and effects. Auphonic integrates with popular external services for seamless uploads and transfers. These connections include Dropbox, Google Drive, and SFTP. This flexibility helps users process massive files without long direct uploads. If your priority is creative effects and unique sound design, Audacity and its plugin support are necessary. If your priority is workflow efficiency and file management, Auphonic wins. Audacity is feature-centric; Auphonic is flow-centric. Professional workflows often begin with creative editing in Audacity and finish with automated mastering via Auphonic integrations.

私たちの判定

機能、価格、ユーザー適合性に基づく客観的なガイダンス。

Audacity and Auphonic are audio tools that serve nearly opposite functions today. Audacity is the free, hands-on workshop for dedicated creatives. Auphonic is the paid, fully-automated factory that produces perfect, consistent results every time. Audacity's undeniable superpower is its zero cost and deep, manual editing capability. You can use Audacity on every operating system and manipulate every sound wave precisely. It remains the best choice for anyone learning audio design or needing local VST functionality. Auphonic's superpower is guaranteed professional consistency achieved using its AI sound engine. Auphonic takes away hours of tedious post-production work like loudness leveling and noise reduction instantly. It is essential for high-volume, reliable content creation for podcasts or audiobooks. The deciding factor is whether you budget money or spend time on post-production. If budget is $0, Audacity wins; accept the archaic interface and potential crashes. If time and guaranteed quality are paramount, Auphonic’s automated system is worth the credit cost. If you need deep, creative editing, choose Audacity. If you need flawless, scalable broadcast-quality sound mastering, Auphonic is the necessary professional solution.

よくある質問

Which tool is better for professional-grade loudness and consistency?

Auphonic is designed specifically for broadcast consistency and uses the Intelligent Leveler automatically. Audacity requires applying manual effects and checking loudness standards yourself. Auphonic guarantees professional results.

Since Audacity is free, is Auphonic worth the cost?

Auphonic is worth the cost if you value automation and guaranteed, perfect consistency across many files. Audacity is free but requires substantial manual labor for similar professional results. Auphonic saves significant production time.

Does Audacity offer automatic shownote generation like Auphonic?

No, Audacity lacks the advanced AI processing features needed for automated tasks. Auphonic uses multilingual speech recognition to generate shownotes and chapters in its paid tiers.

Is Auphonic suitable for deep, creative waveform editing?

No. Auphonic is purely a robust post-processing tool accessed via a web interface. Audacity is the proper desktop editing application for manual cutting and detailed manipulation. Use Audacity for editing first.

Which software is more stable and reliable for large projects?

Auphonic is more reliable as its processing happens in a stable cloud environment. Audacity has known complaints about crashing and project recovery failures in recent versions. Auphonic offers peace of mind.

Can Audacity integrate with external cloud services like Google Drive?

Audacity is a local desktop editor focused on local files or the companion Audio.com. Auphonic integrates natively with Dropbox, SFTP, and Google Drive for seamless mass uploads.

選択する準備はできましたか?

両方のツールにはそれぞれの強みがあります。特定のニーズに基づいて選択してください。